Codependency and when to leave the relationship
Submitted by outdoorsgirl1974 on Fri, 10/24/2008 - 16:20
As I read a lot of posts,I see the same issue of the non ADD spouse wondering when enough is enough.My question is a two part one and I am interested to hear what Melissa has to say as well as others thoughts.
At what point do you leave the relationship and when is it considered being codependant and "Unhealthy?"
It seems ADD by nature has all the codependant signs to go with it.It sets you up for being that way as a lot of times your forced to "take care" of everything.You then get into trying to control their actions,mothering,nagging,etc. for the well being of the family.So is it not considered codependant and a "Healthy relationship" if they ARE self sufficient?(Taking meds,counseling,reading the books,trying hard to be responsible,etc.)However if they are NOT making an effort at all then it would be considered an "Unhealthy relationship"??Am I understanding that correctly?
As I currently am in a class for this very thing..codependancy,which is very helpful...for me it raises the question...Ok how is this different than a drug/alchohol/sexual addiction where they refuse to change or get help?In that case,anyone would say..."Oh yes!The healthy decision is to get out of the relationship ASAP and move on with healing yourself!"Yet when it is ADD you get a different response of..."Well they have ADD and can't help it so you should be sympathetic and put up with it." My question is,how is it different when they ALL show the same behaviors of not wanting to change?Granted,those are addictions and this is ADD,but the behaviors are the same of refusing to change and telling you where they think you should put those books,ideas of counseling,etc...where the sun don't shine...if you know what I mean.
It just seems that no one speaks of the facts,that being in an ADD relationship COULD be unhealthy.Instead of..."Oh you need to work with them,feel sorry for them,etc!"Don't they have the same responsibilites as all responsible adults do in this world?The consequences of the alcholic who won't go to rehab is he looses his family.The consequence all too often with ADD is that the partner sticks it out and trys even harder next time and so the cycle continues.I agree that you have to try all avenues and be willing to work at it...but there comes a point when some of us are starting to give up who we are as individuals in extreme ways.Is it as simple as..."If they are willing to work with you and are open to change...then stay.If they are not willing to work with you at all and refuse to change...leave!"I don't know because there are so many excuses society puts out there because its "ADD",so it makes it a double edged sword for the non ADD spouse and you feel so guilty if you do leave....because after all,"they can't help it!"I am not trying to be mean...its just something to think about.
I told my therapist just last week what is going on in my relationship....all the very same things everyone on here talks about.The frustration,the sadness,the loneliness,the anger,etc and her response was..."Your not in a healthy relationship".So doesn't that proove my argument correct?After all..thats coming from a professional.Anytime your needs aren't being met,thats considered unhealthy....right?So I then told her...."Well...OK...but he doesn't beat me,he isn't verbally abusive,doesn't cheat,etc."She said,thats setting the standard too low.Your settling for a relationship that isn't working for you".A lot of these posts are..."not working for the non ADD partner"...so what do you do?They refuse to change or "not recognize how their ADD affects everything"....so when do you leave if it turns "Unhealthy"?How long SHOULD you put up with it?If it was a drunk were talking about,society would say get out...NOW!Its all the same feelings for the spouse...so if you think about it,what is the difference?I also get how it is a personal decision for everybody and it isn't anyone else's place to determine when YOU should get out and in the end it does have to be your decision...but just some general opinions would be great!
I may be completely in left field on this,but I keep thinking about it..what is anybody else's thoughts?



Comments
Feeling alone and ready to leave
by Still Smiling - 10/31/2008 - 15:18
Hello everyone. This is my first post. I am feeling very alone right now. I have not talked to anyone about this and am scared. I have been married for 19 years to a spouse that I am almost certain has ADHD. He has not be diagnosed and has obviously never been on meds. He has a sibling that has been diagnosed and a father that demonstrates many ADHD symptoms.
My spouse is hard to live with. He is impulsive and can say things that are hurtful then will only apologise later after much prodding. It is very hard for him to relax. I feel guilty reading a book or just reading email messages because he will make me feel guilty for not being busy on housework or giving him attention. He starts out many projects at once and has many irons in the fire at one time. He collapses in bed after running around all day doing it all.
He rarely gives me attention and affection without prodding. I feel like a whiner and hate to have to ask. I dress up for an evening out and he says nothing. I come home with work stories and he is elsewhere (staring off into space...). I feel so alone and hurt. I am ready to leave. I have recently mentioned that he may have ADHD and he has come back defensive and sarcastic.
I don't want to give ultimatums. I am not sure that I want to continue living like this (with him) anymore. I am starting to imagine a life alone where I am happier and responsible only for my own emotional wellbeing. Help, I need some support.
Feeling alone and ready to leave
by At Wit's End - 11/01/2008 - 13:17
At Wit's End
by MelissaOrlov - 11/03/2008 - 19:57
Can you afford professional help? It's one thing not to talk in general about your husband's dependencies, but you can most certainly get some support from a therapist, and it sounds as if you really need it! Don't go through this alone! Keep going to the al anon meetings, etc., too.
See if you can work with your therapist to set up specific boundaries for what's workable in your marriage and what isn't. You don't wish to move from verbal abuse to physical abuse (if you do, move out immediately), and you need to find a way to get the verbal abuse to stop in your relationship. Marriages are for support and happiness, not misery. Set rules that make sense for you, assure him that you aren't going to try to change him, but that you have certain standards for living with anyone (including him) because you respect yourself, then hold him to those standards. If he wants to have you stay together, he'll start to work on his ADD and alcoholism (HE can go to al anon, too!). If not, then you'll know what you need to do. You deserve happiness...insist that if he really, truly loves you he gets the help he needs to show it. Else you will assume that his actions (mean words, etc) demonstrate his true feelings and that he is willing to deal with the consequences like an adult.
Melissa
I Know
by Anonymous - 01/07/2009 - 00:08
Still Smiling...sort of
by MelissaOrlov - 11/03/2008 - 20:14
Both you and your husband should seek medical help. He may have things other than ADD that he might be able to address with the help of a full evaluation and you would benefit from some support, as well as help learning how to express your needs to him. Also, it sounds as if joining a local support group for spouses with ADHD could help you a lot. Ask your doctor for recommendations, or go to the CHADD and ADDA websites for ideas of those in your area who might know of some.
His response to the ADHD comment is not atypical - it's very threatening to feel as if you might have something that might stigmatize you in some people's minds and your bringing it up to him suggests you are unhappy (which you are), which is also "threatening". But eventually he will have to deal with his issues in terms of how he relates to you or you will leave him. So you have a choice...continue to bring it to his attention in creative, hopefully non-threatening ways, or live life the same (which seems unacceptable). A therapist can help you determine the best way to approach him.
The distraction inherent in ADD is hard to deal with. It makes the non-ADD spouse feel really, really lonely. It's terrible to feel that you are 25th on your husband's list of things to pay attention to. Please know that his lack of attention is not personal. It's not because you are somehow deficient. It is because he has ADD and is distracted, that's all. Also, he hasn't learned to read social and emotional cues very well. This means he can't "read" when you are needing his attention. You can even tell him point blank - "I'm lonely and I need your attention" and he still won't seem to get it! Again, this isn't personal.
But, even though it isn't personal, you have a right to insist it change. He has a responsibility to be a good partner to you, and right now his ADD symptoms are getting in the way of that. So try to have some conversations with him that things aren't working for you in the marriage. You need certain things (his attention at least some of the time, for example). You suspect that ADD symptoms may be playing a role in your issues because of what you've read, and you think that it would be great if he might explore whether or not he might have ADD. He can do this by simply reading Delivered from Distraction - an easy request. Furthermore, you might tell him that while you suspect ADHD, you don't care whether or not he has ADD...you only care that the way that you interact improves. You aren't looking to "label" him, only to provide creative input into how you might mutually start to address some of your relationship issues. (You can say "mutually" here, because if he does confirm he has ADD, then that also provides YOU with a roadmap for how to start working together better.)
In the short term, don't set yourself up for disappointment. Don't expect him to notice if you dress up, for example. ADDers are notoriously bad noticers of stuff like that (until they train themselves to notice...which is a different stage from the one you're in now). Don't feel guilty about what YOU are doing. You have a right to do emails, or read a book. See if there are ways you can do that "together", for example sitting in the same room, if you feel that you want to. Learn to get his attention before starting your work stories. Ask him "I would love to tell you a story about work. Do you want to hear it?" for example. Then, make it short and easy to listen to for someone with a short attention span.
Experiment a bit. Some people with ADD concentrate better with music playing. Though it drives me nuts, my husband is much more likely to listen to me if there is a radio playing in the room. Will this work for you?
The underlying issue here may well be untreated ADD (or untreated something else)...get the support you need immediately, then communicate clearly your needs.
Melissa
I could have written your
by Anonymous - 01/07/2009 - 00:14
adhd husband
by Anonymous - 11/03/2008 - 10:42
ADHD and relationships
by Anonymous - 11/03/2008 - 20:22
ADHD & relationships
by Anonymous - 11/05/2008 - 02:39
ADHD & relationships
by martoadd - 01/23/2009 - 20:40
How did you get to the point that life would be better if you walked it alone. Do you have children?
adhd and relationships
by Anonymous - 01/27/2009 - 14:43
Vent!!
by Karen - 11/27/2008 - 23:01
Bitter it is!
by Ildi - 01/29/2009 - 04:28
Not sure how to face 2009
by Mia - 12/31/2008 - 15:55
I just found this site today, New Year's Eve, and I am amazed at how many people are dealing with the same things I have been. I have felt so alone and isolated.
I have been married for 23 years. My husband was never diagnosed with ADD as a child, although he is certain he has it. His never manifested in overt "hyper" behaviors in school, mostly confusion and an inability to concentrate.
I'm horrified now to think for all this time I have been enabling him not to have to deal with it. I knew him well when we married. I knew what worked for us and how to keep peace. As years went on, I knew things he wouldn't face or face without me to "hold his hand." I did a lot on my own--sat at a lot of school functions, family functions, obilgations "without a date." I live in a somewhat remodeled house where nothing ever quite gets done. I make a lot of compromises.
Conflicts followed a pattern of, regardless who caused the offense, it would be me to finally go to him, even if I had to swallow my pride or stuff my anger, to restore our relationship. It was easy with little things.
Last year, he did something that hurt me very deeply and I couldn't just let it go. I was determined for once, to have him find a way to make up with me. He couldn't. My continued hurt would hurt him and his increased stress and frustration made things worse.
We have been able to talk, in the middle of all the fighting, and for the first time looked into what ADD can mean for adults--much more than we knew--and he is seeing a doctor on Monday.
I guess what I need to know is if he is diagnosed, and if he does take medication, I would expect it to help the wanting to go a million different directions and the inability to organize and the not being able to sit still, etc. But will it help him empathize? Will he be able to think before he speaks and realize how hurtful he can be? If I ask him to do something, can I ever expect him to see it might make me happy and do it?
Standing up for myself finally has made my life very hard. Right now staying in the marriage and leaving the marriage both seem like terrible options. I'm just looking for some hope.
To Mia
by Anonymous - 01/01/2009 - 06:42
More questions
by Mia - 01/04/2009 - 17:36
I know I need to wait until tomorrow to start getting ANY answers, but I wonder if not dealing with it at all until you're in your 40s means things really won't change that much. As I read about meds, therapy, coaching, etc., someone his age could be pretty well adjusted by now, unless he had a wife who always smoothed things over, made excuses for him and did everything herself...
As I told him ( and we didn't fight when I said it, believe it or not) for 22 years, I lived with the hope things would get better. I'd see little victories--something would get done or he'd step out of his comfort zone a little. Now, I'm afraid things will never change. Maybe even get worse.
And I'm afraid of what the rest of my life will be like. Like I said in my previous post. Staying or going both seem like terrible options.
Mia
by Anonymous - 01/05/2009 - 09:18
doctor's appointment
by Mia - 01/06/2009 - 17:35
He went to the doctor yesterday. There are actually also some test results that aren't quite right, so he is having blood work and another test to look into that. As for ADHD, the doctor told him "I won't give you medicine today."
I'm surprised he'd give him medicine at all actually. I thought there'd be a referral to a mental health professional.
That might be in the plan, though. My husband is supposed to get his tests, then return for a follow up and bring me to talk to the doctor.
Only problems: more waiting, no answers and ducking all the time when I think the next bomb will drop...
self centeredness
by Anonymous - 01/06/2009 - 20:53
waiting
by optomistic - 01/07/2009 - 04:59
Hello, I'am new to this forum so I'am a little shy to write this. But I share this to maybe help someone. I have been married for twelve yrs to a husband who has Adhd and depression and is also a alcoholic. I have many stories I could share. I understand about the next bomb falling there are times we have to walk on eggshells at my house. This summer my husband decided to go work in another state because he had lost his job. The gas was shut off, phone etc.. He left and went to his cousins for a week to fish etc... before he went to work. when he did go to work he was there for over a month, went gambling got kick out where he was staying. that day he told me everything was fine but he was lying. He went back to his cousins (it was 4th of july weekend) didn't answer the phone and I had no idea what happened to him. He finally came home and told me about what he did. I was flabbergasted. My anger was seeping and oozing out of me. He never sent me any money the whole time he was gone( he had told me it was in the mail) and among the stories he told me he pawned off our wedding ring because he had spent all his money and needed gas for the car.Well I had a emotional breakdown. I went to a good friend who talked me into going to the hospital because she could see that I was on shutdown mode. I spent 4 days in the hospital and met a lot of people. I had time to relax and understand myself more and some of him. I learned a lot about healthy boundaries. I asked my husband to come so we could speak to a counselor at the hospital. The next day the nurse told me she "saw what I was dealing with"! I don't think my husband ever understood how I really felt. After that I got better because I have a strong faith and many praying friends. My husband and I ended up separating and He had gotten a good chunck of change which he spent at his leisure. I had given him our bills and they ended up wrinkled and unpaid on the bottom of the car floor. Also at this time our house was in forecloser and some other major things happened. . For today we are back together for how long? only God knows. Why do I stay? I have 4 beautiful children who we both love so much and it would devestate them if we divorced. I have decided not to let his toxic thoughts take over my life . I fight it in my mind. I recently learned that with fear based thoughts, stress. we form thorn like shapes which releases chemicals in our brains in wrong quantities and causes chemical imbalances, I'am getting a book called WHO SWITCHED OFF MY BRAIN. by caroline leaf. talks about it. I also choose to look at life and its beauty. I have been through a lot but I choose not for it to destroy my world! I don't mean to sound trite but have a cup of tea, relax and enjoy nature. Take time to see the beautiful side of life. Theres always ugliness in the world but only you can choose your path. Whichever way you go you are not alone:} If you would have talked to me a few months ago I would have told you I'am at my wits end. But now I choose not to be.
To Optimistic
by MelissaOrlov - 01/08/2009 - 18:03
I really like your attitude - taking your own life into your hands. I also like that you are working in the present. When you say "we are back together for today but for how long, only God knows" that seems to be a pretty healthy way to look at it. I suspect that you are working from the standpoint of thinking that you are in a "relationship" rather than a "marriage" and that is good - it encourages people to set and maintain boundaries, I think - very healthy.
On the other hand, please be careful not to get sucked into a situation which is meaningless for you as a person. You need to make sure that you are happy enough, not just surviving for the sake of your kids. Perhaps a good goal would be to BOTH take time to see the beautiful side of life AND make sure your standards for how you spend your days are high. If you are letting bad feelings fester inside, under a veneer of relaxing, then ultimately it will catch up with you. You'll be able to tell the difference if you think about it. (I "put on a good face" for a while in my marriage, but that didn't last...later I actually changed how I approached my life and that DID work.) Make sure that your goal is your happiness (whatever that entails, which may well include creating a stable home for your kids) NOT staying married.
Keep us apprised of your progress, if you will, because I think lots of readers can learn from your experience.
Melissa
Re:to Melissa
by optomistic - 01/17/2009 - 12:38
Thanks Melissa for the post. I couldn't agree with you more. Sad to say that as of this moment my husband and now are seperated.
Things are not getting better and I'am tired of the drinking and dirty looks and desrespect. We both felt this was healthier for our children as well.
My husband threatened me with a lawyer but I suggested to seperate for now since we cannot afford a lawyer. We are meeting with a crisis counselor who will help us draw up the papers legally so if we do get divorced then we have half the work done. I Think it will take a miracle for us to remain married. I tried really and at times he did too. However when you do damaging things as I wrote previously and on top of that other devastating things I really understand the lack of good judgement in him. I know that there are many people on this forum who are hurting on both sides who are seeking answers. Mental illness is not easy to understand cope with. I have a little experience with it because my mother suffered with post tramatic stress from WW2 she was from Europe. So I saw the effects as a child, which I think has given me more understanding but living with it is another story. life's journey is not always smooth but having a healthy attitude, good boundaries and loving kindness will help. Don't expect to shape or even always understand mental illness, that can make you unhealthy. Just except it and know what you are dealing with. Life is a gift from God and we are all gifts.I'am still drinking my tea and enjoying nature. thanks for reading.
boundaries
by MelissaOrlov - 01/08/2009 - 16:01
It's great that your husband will see a doc. Meds may well help with impulse control, which will help him hold his tongue a bit, but meds don't work alone...he also has to make a commitment to make behavioral changes. For you, it sounds as if he needs to learn how to own his mistakes and apologize for them (a counsellor may be able to help with this, as might a couples communications course). This might also be a good time to open the communications between the two of you a bit more (your reference to being able to talk even in the fighting is a good sign). If you haven't before, you can tell him how hard it is for you to feel that you must always be the peacemaker, etc.
Also, see my recent post about setting boundaries. It's a bit theoretical, but it may help you. It sounds to me as if one of your boundaries needs to be an ability to express your feelings - and have them recognized as legitimate - by your husband.
I think it is safe to say that not very many ADD men are good at anticipating what their spouse wants of them, and many aren't that good at doing a chore to make their wife happy (even after medication). My husband finally made that leap, but it was only after our relationship had gotten back to a happy place - in other words after there were no power struggles going on and after he was feeling loving towards me again. Before that he simply wasn't feeling expansive enough towards me to make the effort. I'm not sure that this is ADD-specific. When we feel badly, we act badly.
As for "standing up for yourself", try to see if it helps to think of it as "doing things that make me happy" vs. "doing things that make me right". In other words, sometimes the best policy IS to back down, ignore something, or accept it. But NOT if that comes at the expense of who you are as a person or living and overall (reasonably) happy life.
Today, My partner had
by Anonymous - 12/31/2008 - 18:31
When DO you leave?
by Steph - 01/07/2009 - 10:01
I can only take so much abuse, neglect and yelling. I recently read in one of Dr H's books not to let ADD end your marriage...let something else. So? How can this work with one person so focused on himself, who "forgets" to take his meds even though he admits he doesn't like the way he feels now while not on them, who only thinks of himself and his immediate needs? How? How can this work?
I emphathize!
by frustrated in Iowa - 01/21/2009 - 17:51
As I go through all of these stories I can relate as well. I have been married for a year with a guy who has ADD. I found out when we were engaged. I called off the wedding originally when he kept racking up speeding ticket after speedng ticket and even after I kept warning him. I found out he had debts from his past that he just decided to ignore and just a bunch of irresponsible things. So I found out it was ADD and that he said he'd get help for it along with Strattera medication. We have seen a counselor for 2 of the three years I have known him and yet i see not all the problems have not gone away. I read Hallowell's book and he suggests that trying several medications often occurs before finding the right one. Well my husband is working just a temp job after losing his last one and is now looking for permanant work for 9 months now. He has been on several interviews but no bites. I attributed it to he's not the best at expressing himself. Also, he was told recently he would have gotten a job if he had passed his reading comprehension test. To me this says he has problems retaining information which i had already figured. Because i told myself if i have to show him how to use spell check one more time on the computer I'm going to lose it. His retention for new information is not good amongst other commom characteristics to ADD. Not to be mean but how did he make it in this world before me? Is the question I always ask myself. I have to take careof everything academically if i want it done and done right. I also understand the blogs on lowering your expectations if you want to live with that person. And don't even get me started on respecting him. How can I respect him when he get very little done and done correctly. I also pity him because there is nothing he is good at. I feel like he fails at everything! I can't imagine going through life like that. And to top it off he doesn't even know how he is or how his ADD affects anyone. I just know he's on Strattera because it helps him sleep and thats it. And yes Strattera has helped some but if I want my husband to get a job he's going to need some serious medication so he can retain information in his brain to keep a job! I'm frustrated b/c the doctor that prescribed his medication tells me he doesn't need anything stronger! hello! You don't live with him day to day to see the stuff he just doesn't "get". its not normal!And yet the doctor never asked me and won't speak to me...which i think is wrong! My question to anyone out there is if I dragged my husband in (and the doctor agrees) to try another medication like ritalin or Adderall, will it help with his retention?? I need a husband who can keep a job because i can't raise him like a teen the rest of my life.