Forum topic: The effectiveness of self-screening

Hi All,

Just wanted to ask you what you thought about the self-screening as the main (or only) diagnostic tool for ADHD. Many therapists do this - base the whole diagnosis on that piece of paper, filled by the patient. And that's it. Voila. You immediately know if you have ADHD.

But I think it's been acknowledged quite widely that people with ADHD may not have enough insight to actually catch those moments and assess their frequency correctly. They have trouble noticing things that impact their environment, remembering those things, and truly understanding them (quite understandably, just like the non might have trouble understanding their point of view), and then there's the whole denial/rationalization system in place.

My SO denies practically everything ADHD-related that happens. There's always an explanation. And if I asked directly: do you do this often? Like, "do you lose your keys on a daily basis?" She confidently replies, "no, I don't". Or "well, very rarely, but that happens to everyone". And she does the same in therapy. When I know for a fact that it happens a few times a week. And it's ONLY talking keys. Add to that mobile, wallet, documents, documents and personal items. Still, the answer is "no".

So, what's the actual value of self-screening with people who still live in total denial? Isn't it like asking someone "are you a liar"? (don't get me wrong, not trying to suggest ADHD-ers are liars) Or "do you forget things"? Or "do you often miss clues"? Even if they do, they wouldn't know, would they?

I'm not blaming her she's totally oblivious, I think I know quite well by now how her brain works. What puzzles me, is how come the therapists never take those factors into account? Nobody asks me if I corrobrate. What she says obviously is truth. "Because if that really happens like you say, it would imply there's some serious issue". Yeah, so? How does that invalidate my experience? And you can't really fight the non-debatable argument "you're obviously noticing those things a lot, try noticing them less; you're obviously over-reacting". Yeah, I notice them a lot because they happen a lot. Yeah, I'm over-reacting because they happen a lot. I told you so at the very beginning: that's the reason I'm here. Not to hear those things don't happen "as often as I think they do". Trust me, I know exactly how often they happen. That's the problem.

That's just another wall in therapy. I've seen it throw back my ADHD partner down into the depths of denial too many times, even when she was actually quite ready to accept the issue and start dealing with it. And you can't just keep finding new therapists, hoping one of them will finally get it. At some point, it starts looking irrational as if you try to desperately stick to your "preconceived theory", no matter how many times they tell you you're wrong, so your chances of convincing your partner and actually helping them fade everytime you switch therapists.

Which is bad, because if you're looking for therapy, it probably means you already feel like you're only half-sane, doubt many of your observations and feel like you don't cope well. The relationship itself is enough to make you feel irrational, you don't need to pay for it.

And I think this must happen when you only do the self-screening. I can see no other way this could go.

So, my question is: has anyone here ever heard of an ADHD candidate in denial being successfully diagnosed this way?

Comments

If you're sure she has ADHD and that she is in 'oblivious' denial, telling her won't cut it. A lot of people with ADHD struggling to 'theorise'. We might be able to work with numbers and understand what it means, but we can't convert it into a proper sense of realism as in how much it affects our life. I know there's five minutes left to catch the bus, I know it takes about 3 to eat some bread, but for some strange reason I think 2 minutes is enough to put on my shoes, walk out the door and run to the next street where the bus is waiting. I might recognise that 2 minutes is a short amount of time, but I can't see how serious it is, no matter how much I tell myself it is.

Ignore trying to prove to her she has ADHD for the time being, prove to her that these symptoms exist and do it pictorially. For example, draw a tally of how many times you've forgotten something and how many times she's forgotten something every day. Expect what might happen. In this case she might realise she's forgotten something yet might be resistant to say she has. If you're both looking for something, then say they have a limit of 2 minutes to find it before it counts as having been forgotten. If you think she has forgotten something, ask if they remember what was mentioned earlier and if they can guess. If not, it counts. Throughout this mention to her how you're doing this not to prove she's a bad person but to show that it's something you are concerned about and that you want to help her out. If she does forget regularly, much more than average, it should become very obvious on her tally chart. If she still denies it after all that, then you know it's no longer oblivious denial but something else.

If she starts defending herself, make it about you. Use the 'I' language. Tell her 'I am concerned' rather than 'you forget all the time'. Let her know 'I want changes because it's affecting my life too' rather than 'you'll never get better at anything if you keep forgetting things' and be prepared to compromise (attempt to cook something nice for her if she puts up with it?). After all, marriages are about compromise and communication so for you to ask of something is not wrong but to not give something of similar value in return may be.

... With regards to your main topic, yes I believe myself that there may be a problem with the way therapists may try to diagnose it in this way by asking the patient questions and placing a lot of emphasis on their statements. Even when they don't deny it, as you've said there is also the problem of their lack of awareness of it and so their testimony alone should not be sufficient.

Thank you for your great post. Let me address the bullet-points:

Theorise. Yes! This happens every step. There's lots of things being done "taking the opportunity" too, like she knows she's already late, because getting to the appointment takes 15 minutes and she only has 10, but since she's going to be passing a novelty shop and needs to buy a present, she'll stop and browse. Mind you, this doesn't happen when she goes by the shop, but not in a hurry. And the twisted ways of time counting really twist my mind, while they seem perfectly logical to the SO. The countless times of arriving 1 (literally one minute) too late, only to find the guard just locking the door... Just like being late for a bus, it's actually a 1/0 result. Either you get there in time and get the task completed, or you don't. So it doesn't actually matter if you're 1 or 15 minutes late. Yet it's always more frustrating, I think, if you see the bus JUST leaving.

Pictorials. I've tried that, and it's not working. Somehow she's still able to deny the fact she did it X times. And she categorizes, which is a neat trick. So "I've only lost my phone once this month". And "I've only lost my keys once this week". And "I've only lost the wallet twice this month". If you sum up ALL the lost objects this month, however - that tells a totally different story.

Making it about me. I've started doing this a lot recently. Trying to break the "you always/you never" pattern, that's one thing. Second, I really feel like it's more and more about me, literally about my sanity. Third, I think it might be easier to appeal to her compassion (which she has tons of, when able to focus): won't do it for yourself, please do it for me, it's really important. Sadly, that seems to be failing with things that are the most important to me.

 

What you suggested are all great methods and I'm trying to follow all of that, with mixed results. In fact, they might be the best ways that are available. However, in this case it seems like they're bringing mediocre results. But probably better than other solutions, so hey, that's something. :)

And about therapy, I'm clueless as to why they stick to those methods with conditions that may include lack of self-awareness. And the more I want to prove my point, the more maniacal I come across, so I won't even go there, I've learned that much.

About that... just wanted to add one thing, followed by a question. :)

I realize it may be easier to cope with everyday struggle of looking for lost objects if you do it this way. But I noticed a strange thing in our conversations and thought maybe you could share some light, since this may be related somehow to what you said.

If I say things 'as a rule', like "you lose objects frequently", she replies: "no, that's not true, give me examples". A-ha, but I'm prepared for this reply these days. So I give specific examples. But then this may go two ways:

- she'll start explaining EVERY example by some external circumstance. Like "I forgot the phone, because I was already late for a meeting". "I forgot keys, because I was distracted by a phone call". "I forgot the wallet, because I was already 5 hrs late for a meeting with you, and since I know you're such a stiff about that, and I had postponed so many times, I felt pressured by you, so it's actually your fault".

- she says "yes, that happened, I have no explanation other than my reluctance, BUT... you're taking an example out of context and making a general rule out of it. So it's a vicious circle: cannot prove a rule without examples. But an example does not make a rule, so here we go. Case closed.

Did you notice any similar pattern in your life? Any idea what's happening here? Do you think it's a secondary thing, like a self-defence mechanism, or rather something that can be attributed directly to ADHD?

This could be a follow up to what I mentioned earlier about having a discussion about symptoms and making sure to include "how much"...or ..."how often".....she does this?

Your examples here and her response are telling to me ( even if I can't read her mind and know for sure )   Like "I forgot the phone, because I was already late for a meeting". "I forgot keys, because I was distracted by a phone call". "I forgot the wallet, because I was already 5 hrs late for a meeting with you, and since I know you're such a stiff about that, and I had postponed so many times, I felt pressured by you, so it's actually your fault".

As I interpret that ( picturing myself saying it "as if".....it sounds like this is what she truly believes.  This is the complete rationalization ( or excuse ) that she has in relationship to her behavior and "why" it happens.  This is in essence...the denial of the truth or denial of what she is unaware of......which I think is a better way to say it?

Out of sight.....out of mind.   Out of mind.....out of sight.  If you can't see it.....then you won't know you do it?   As a defense mechanism, it would allow you to deny what you cannot bring yourself to see and refuse to take responsibility for?  The blaming or pointing the finger at you....as the person who "made me do it"....is simply denial in itself.  Out of mind......out of sight   Not wanting to look....or refusal to see  for fear of what you might see which you don't want to think about?

The second I get too close to this with my wife for example.....she will interrupt, shut you down (and with me as my T called it ).....she will "muzzle me", or prevent me from saying it and stop before if I get too close or attempt to tell her what she is doing?  This is in part.....what I noticed in our session together.  He will avoid at all costs....speaking directly to her about her part in our interactions with is highly frustrating to me since "my part" is clearly being discussed right out in the open and I have no problem admitting or saying I do anything I am aware that I do? 

And so even if, I am "aware" but I don't see things at times......Out of sight....out of mind.....and I miss something or simply "did not see it"saying....as my language would say "I am aware that I do these things.  I am also aware that I miss things too at times.  I am also aware because of the nature of my ADHD.....I might not see something that is obvious even to me at times, or possibly aware that I might not notice how often or how much....I know the nature of my ADHD causes this to happen so "I am aware" I do these things.....I'm sorry, please excuse me because: " I missed this"..."I didn't see it but now I see ( even Thank you for pointing this out to me....that was helpful for me to know )".....or simply "crap,  I did that again....I hate that when that happens, that much be really frustrating"..."or at worst with no real acknowledgment of the other person"......"shit!!  Brain fart!!  ADHD moment!!"....."God damn it....here I am, being me!! ( I'm such an idiot )"...in a more self defeating or "beating myself up" kind of way.

I can only speculate what the difference is here between my wife and I ( even before I knew I had ADHD ) but the fact that my feet were always held to the fire ( and blame seemed to fall on me ) (shit rolls down hill ) on and on.....with me at home for example....I was ( as I saw it )....always guilty and to blame for everything "I'm the one to blame!!"  This was my conditioned response and I was always "responsible" even if I wasn't responsible if you get the difference here?  I took on "responsibility" automatically, so I would beat myself up constantly for what I had no idea of or no awareness of...since that was the expectation and accusations leveled against me?  Responsibility was a big theme in our household ( pretty much across the board ).  I was always "guilty"..and walked around "guilty" before I even opened my mouth or did anything?  The fact is, I accepted that as "fact"...and that is what I believed? Or you could say...."made to believe"...by my accusers.  It was "Out of Sight"...but I knew it was there?  It was invisible and I couldn't see it.....but it was always my fault.  Guilty as charged.

This is what the ADHD meds did for me in part or in a huge way.  It was like getting "glasses" so I could "see" what was invisible.  How many ways can I say this...which brings one thing to mind in another variation of what they say to Artists too.  If you can "see it"......you can draw it. "Seeing is believing".....and so on and so forth...it speaks to the same thing?  In fact....there is no secret to why I could draw things so well a a kid or even now for the same reason? ( the gift of sight I call it )  It's really not that hard to understand even if you can't do this yourself?  If you had a bowl of fruit to draw a still life from....you are simply looking at the "scene" or "still life" and painting it or drawing it right?  Well, if you can "see that image in your mind...that clearly and vividly...like looking at a photograph, you are simply doing the same thing?  Your just copying the picture in your mind...and drawing it on paper?  Not that hard to figure out even if you don't have that "picture" so clear and vividly displayed?  Visualizing...could be called "virtualizing"....."virtual image"......not just vague undefined or unclear..."images". 

Even the definition of "Virtual Reality" says: the computer-generated simulation of a three-dimensional image or environment that can be interacted with in a seemingly real or physical way by a person using special electronic equipment, such as a helmet with a screen inside or gloves fitted with sensors. 

Okay, so with me....I don't need a computer-generated simulation.....to see the 3 dimensional image (in my head)  My brain does that for me....I can see that same "Virtual Reality"...very close to accurately "clearly" in the pictures in my head?  In 3d ?  I can move it around and look at all side of it....and then just copy it on paper and draw it?  It's not the "skill with my hands and a pencil".....it's just copying what "I see"?  It's so simply and easy to understand and it's even more simple and easy to do?  Simple and easy....piece of cake...no problem?  If you can see it....you can draw it?  What's so hard to understand?

So for me....I can't understand why everyone can't do this?  In fact, I use to think everyone can but as I have come to realize....this is not the case?  I have never known, anything but this so why would I assume otherwise going back to my first recollection?  And or course...it developed at time went on? This I can do in my sleep...in fact, my dreams are so real sometimes....I think I was there or actually really "lived" the dream?  Nightmares are or were especially frightening when I was a child?  I use to "talk in my sleep nightly " according to my sisters who would hear me talking away and then tell me what I said in the morning?  And I use to walk in my sleep all the time too...but normally, it was due to some kind of night terror like being chased by wild animals and attacked by them and they were trying to eat me?  I woke up one time...standing in my front yard in my underwear...when a Tiger was chasing me...and I ran down the hall of our home, opened the front door, vaulted a brick flower planter and ended up waking up standing in my front yard in the middle of the night?  Those dreams were so real...that I actually acted them out physically and this was usually when I would do that?  And I could draw it, in very clear detail exactly as my "Virtual Reality Dream" in my mind was "as I saw it" that clearly and detailed just like a movie or photograph?  I can still see those images even today...right now as I am writing this?  I can still see the mountain lion, or the animal that was attacking me...where I was and see the lions face...just like it actually happened and I was actually there?  I could draw it clearly....just as I see it in my mind?  If you can see it......you can draw it?  Out of sight.....out of mind.......means, I just don't see it...or I didn't see it.....but, just because a tree falls in the forest and no one is there to see it....does it still make a sound?  Well yes!!   Of course it does?  What kind of question is that?  That's a stupid question since the answer IS SO OBVIOUSLY YES!!! lol 

But as I am saying this.....it is not so obvious to everyone else and that's kind of the point I am trying to make?  Out of sight....out of mind.....does not mean it is not there?  What it means is, you can't see it, but you know that it is?

Out of mind, out of sight....does not mean the same thing?  Out of mind......means there is no picture?  There is no image or picture you can draw on a piece of paper?  If you cannot see it....you cannot draw it?  No Virtual Reality....movie or image...you can see?


I may be getting too far into this or too "deep" into this discussion....but I kind of realize that this is part of what happens with me too at times with people but especially my wife for example.  If I can't "see it" then I know there is a problem?  I know it because I "see everything" like this and always have so if I can't see it...then I know something is wrong?  It doesn't mean .."it isn't there or it doesn't exist"...it means I just can't see it which I know what that means? "I CAN'T SEE IT"  My language then would say....I am guilty of not seeing it if I can't see it?  I can't blame anyone else for the fact that I can't see it or I don't get it?  That makes me guilty of not seeing....automatically without thinking anything else?

This was an interesting discovery that I am still thinking hard about?  As it's been mentioned...that "shame' is a big factor here and people with ADHD carry around a lot of shame or can....depending on?  What I remember more than anything else and the pervasive feeling that haunted me was...."guilt" or "feeling guilty".  I was always "guilty" and it was always "my fault".  I think "shame" was a secondary thing as you were mentioning this or speculating this idea?

I was, and still am....very hard on myself or can be do to this very thing?  If you are always "guilty"...then defense against "guilt" would be your primary defense you would employ or use to avoid "being guilty".  Blame...has alreayd been established, so you really can't blame anyone else if you are always guilty I suppose?  That would have been me....more often than not?  Instead of the Scarlet letter of "Shame"....I had just had a big "G" painted on my forehead....blame and shame were not really on the table or the forefront of this if you can understand it from that vantage point?  Telling me, I did something...even with no awareness of it ( or even IF I was not guilty or to blame ) when you are always scape goated...and shit rolls down hill...then if you are at the bottom of the hill....then you pretty much know that too?  If I was accused of anything ( my fault or not )....I was "guilty first"....."innocent second".....that was how that worked so I'd be apt to say.."Yes....I likely did that even if I can't see it?  I'm the one to blame"

That is part of the "stench" problem I have from that kind of abuse but it's just left over habits that are hard to get rid of completely?  It's difficult to wash that completely off you ....but the language is different...if "guilt" is involved?

I'm speculating here but as it appears to me with my wife is just the opposite of me in many ways?  From her position, which sounds similar to your partner....both of them add that "and you made me do it...you're the one to blame and it's actually your fault"

This is that "Perry Mason" line again at the breakdown at the end of the show when the murderer cries out "but don't you understand....I had to do it!!!"  

No....I don't understand?  You're Fucking Guilty.....no one made you do anything? ( sheese!!! ) LOL    Out of mind.....out of sight   That's called denial right there.  Different, than Out of sight....out of mind..........if you get the actually less than subtle difference?

That's not to say I don't do that or haven't done it.....but my standard or conditioned MO....is "guilty first"   before all esle.( shit rolls down hill, and if you're at the bottom?? )  That's the point, and a different perspective and being able to "see".  It's what the meds did for me in spades.  Like getting a new pair of glasses, that I never had before?  But as I'm saying this....."not being able to see"....is different, that not 'wanting to"  or "refusing to"...for what ever reason or and the purpose to protect from?  I'm guessing "SHAME"...in that case......not so much "guilt" if you can see the difference which is what I think this is?

That's my best guess and using myself in contrast to what I ran into with my wife...as the possible differences and why that is?  And being able to visualize....which was a "gift" right from the start?  My wife appears to be completely challenged with anything visually but maybe that's just me since I can do it much better than her?  I don't know where the lines begin and end there either?  I am not inside anyone elses head to know what they actually see? ( visually speaking that is )  I take that for granted...but I'm thinking now I shouldn't?   I have a great deal of trouble "audibly" with instructions so I am failry challenged there except......the Adderall REALLY REALLY ...helped me there, almost immediately?  I was amazed...at all the things I was missing...in what I "heard".....more than what I saw? 

I could say the Adderall....was like getting a virtual "Hearing Aid"......almost more than "Glasses" but to say both....weighted more toward hearing in my case?  For what that's worth to anyone else?  But I also have always had "sound clips" in my head too?  Not the just visucal picture...but the words in the sound clip...."or music"?  Same thing as the "photograph".  Sound "clips" are the same thing?  I can hear the "song" and the words both but the words people say "stick" in there permanently almost?  Just the "clips" not thye entire conversation?  But usually , those "clips" are really important since they are normally when something doesn't make sense and they "stick"...in "pergatory" LOL....my permanent temporary holding place or "unfinished business" file...that is saved for later until the answer finally comes?  But sometimes there is no answer like: "It's clouds illusions I recall....I really don't know clouds, at all?"  What's to understand?  It's a frick'in cloud for crying out loud? LOL

J

Hi smd1409,

Just had another clash. She promised to do a small thing for me a few days back (doesn't matter what; point is, I can't do it myself).

Today, she told me in the morning she had plenty of work (not related to my request), but spent her whole day relaxing, doing many different things she likes (like meeting friends, chatting over internet, but mostly just spread on the sofa, reading random internet articles on her mobile). Those usually come first, until some really close deadline at work breaks the procrastination. Ok, I don't mind, as long as it does not affect me directly. But I really need her to make good on her promise, it's important for me.

So I proceeded the way I usually do. I said "I'm concerned you still haven't done what I asked for, even though I reminded you gently so many times. I'm not angry at you. It makes me sad, but that's also not the point. I just need you to do it." As expected, her reaction was "I didn't have time, because this and that happened." I said "I'm not talking about why. I know you meant to do it. I am not going to discuss why it didn't happen. It doesn't matter. I just need you to do it, preferably now." She said: "I meant to do it this morning, but then received a call and had to attend to this other thing, so I couldn't, so stop blaming me." I said: "I'm not blaming you. I didn't say anything about blame or guilt. I just need you to do this". She: "Ok, you didn't, I misspoke. Slip of the tongue." I said: "No, I don't think it was, I think you were quite clear. I realize you might have heard accusation. I cannot be sure, I'm not in your head. But in case you did, please know I wasn't accusing you. I just need you to do this thing." She said: "I will. Why are you always suggesting I won't?" I said: "I am not suggesting anything, I am just telling you I need you to do it." She: "And I really meant to." I: "I know you meant to. I know you meant well. But you didn't, so I'm asking again. And I really know how and why it happened. You don't have to explain it to me. It took me a long time to understand why these things happen, but I do. Thanks to what I know and because I understand this, I can be more patient and not be angry at you." She: "Don't try suggesting I'm not seeing things clearly. Remember, I still haven't been diagnosed. In fact, the therapist suggests you might be the one who sees thing incorrectly, only noticing the times I fail. Can't you see I'm trying? Can't you see I'm successful with so many things?" I: "I know that. I can see you're trying. I really appreciate it. About the diagnosis, I don't really care. We're not talking why, and it doesn't matter how we label it. That's not what we're talking about. We're talking about doing that one thing you promised to do."

Finally, she said she'll do it tonight. Interesting phrasing, btw: "I still believe I can do this tonight". And I just couldn't say "I know you will". When I do it, she often ticks it off as done, and I really wanted her to do that thing. Besides, fighting the constant denial, I've recently introduced a policy of being totally honest. And besides, when I generalize after the fact, she often says "you should have told me while it was happening, because now I can't recall it; if you don't pinpoint these things for me, I assume you're ok with them". So, instead I said "I know you believe you will". To which she responded with the usual "you undercut me, you don't believe in me", and I stopped it, saying it's not about that. I'm not a prophet, I cannot know if that will actually happen or won't. I'm just saying I trust what she says, and not commenting on what she will. So she says: "I believe [here's that phrasing again] you're wrong saying I don't usually keep my word. I believe I am very reliable." To which I said "I believe you're in denial, but I won't try to break this wall again tonight. I'm just too tired and can't have this discussion right now. It's just my word against yours, I say it happens, you say it doesn't. We're discussing facts, I can't be discussing facts. Let's just see what happens, ok?" She: "I think you're already assuming I have ADHD (even though there's no diagnosis) and you see what you wanna see. You're assuming I'm not reliable and I won't do it. And even the T says the truth is in the middle, so you're exaggerating a lot, and this is also how I feel." I: "I understand you might feel this way. We just see the world differently. I've come to accept that and for now I can live with it. So, please, just do this thing." She: "Are you suggesting I don't know what I'm doing? Because you're clearly convinced I live in Matrix and you're the only one who lives in reality. I can't believe how sure you are that you're seeing things correctly and I don't. How do you know it's not the other way round? I'm very careful when it comes to giving strong opinions, because I know I might be seeing things subjectively. Why won't you admit you see things subjectively too?" I: "This is going nowhere. I won't try to make you believe what I believe. I may be wrong, as well as you. I'm not saying my view is better than yours. I just know they're different." She: "I don't think they're that different, you're just stubborn. I think we both see things in a very similar way." To which I finally said: "The very conversation proves it's not so. But please, let's not talk about it today, I'm really tired and can't be doing it. Let's just drop it. Just do the thing." She: "You'll be surprised. Fucking unbelievable, how little you believe in me. Suggesting like I'm crazy or something. You're tho one who's in Matrix." Then I said this was going too far and changed the subject (with no resistance from her).

But guess what. I wasn't surprised. She went to the sofa, ("cos I'm really tired"), spent another 1/2 hour reading random articles and fell asleep in her clothes.

I know tomorrow she's going to deny this happened, or say "yes, I know I said I would do it, but I was really tired, so I think I'm entitled to fall asleep when I'm tired", or "it didn't need doing yesterday so I decided I'd wake up earlier today, do all the things that are in the way, and then do what you asked; it was a very responsible decision, because this way I can do it even better; yesterday I was tired, so the results would have been mediocre, but today I'm well rested, so I can do it the way it should be done", or some other crap like this. Problem is, when she does this, it's like the discussion never happened. Just saying "I will to it later" for the thousandth time erases the whole issue, resets the story so it comes back to the beginning and we can start the drill again. It's like the time is rewound. Not sure if it's Matrix or Groundhog Day.

The second thing that worries me a lot is that she really doesn't see the pattern. Tomorrow she'll deny it happened or underplay it.

The third thing is that she's ready to have all this discussion to convince me I'm not seeing things as they are, and then she proves my point by not doing it.

Fourth: she defends herself very aggressively, even though I'm not really attacking.

Fifth: she very often refers to what the T said, making me think the therapy is not helping but doing some serious damage.

Sixth: the thing is still not done and I know I'll have to go through all that all over again.

It's really hard on me to be having these conversations. Trying to stick to the point is like trying to hold a very slippery live fish. And it always makes me realize how far we are from her really understanding her own problem and that there's literally nothing I can do to make her. So far, she's not read anything about it (she promised to, many weeks ago, and I keep reminding her from time to time - same story). I know I get her much better then she gets me, because she's not even familiar with what ADHD really is: she keeps saying things that literally make no sense about it, like "I don't think I have it, I don't lack focus, I even think sometimes I focus too much, so it can't be ADHD". I mean, come on. Really?

Thus said, I also keep wondering if maybe I'm making a mistake somewhere? I try doing it by the book, being honest, but also showing love and support, stressing how much I care and appreciate her will to do it... But maybe you have some advice for me, maybe you could suggest some different approach?

I'm coming back here to possibly fill in some blanks but as I read through this, it occurred to me ( really exactly what is going on? )  This is the telling part to me since to say "I don't do these "things" is not  specific enough to actually be very helpful?  "Specifics" and being very "explicit" are the key words I keep hammering into my wife as she will start in with the same kind of situation you are describing?   To say, "I don't do this"....might imply, that I don't get distracted by the things you mentioned in this description:

... but spent her whole day relaxing, doing many different things she likes (like meeting friends, chatting over internet, but mostly just spread on the sofa, reading random internet articles on her mobile). Those usually come first, until some really close deadline at work breaks the procrastination. Ok, I don't mind, as long as it does not affect me directly. But I really need her to make good on her promise, it's important for me.

For me, it's really easy for me to see myself doing this?  But to say, I do this "just like this"...is neither true nor accurate.  Have I ever done this?  Sure I have, plenty of times...but this hits upon my immediately recalling...."when "I use to do this very thing" and I go....but not any more?   But even as I look back now, and recall when I have done "things like this"....I can also "critique myself" and objectively "see, what I did...and what I didn't do"and actually  remember when I did?   This is a curious thing to me now since I can remember it pretty clearly?  I can simply look back and go  "yeah, been there, done that"....and say "yeah, I apt or likely to do this even now if I am not paying attention?"

But even then...and even "when I would do this very thing or even now....."IF I decide to do it"...I actually see a choice being made...as well as seeing myself doing something somewhat different, even back then which is also curious to me?

This whole notion about  "you know, I know what I did....and I know what I didn't do" might be true or not coming from me as you hear me?  I've already got that suspicion of doubt hanging over my head but maybe for your sake, I can tell you what "I did" in the same situation?  I learned a long time ago ( a very long time ago ) to do things first.  Meaning, I understood if I didn't do it "now"....it would get done "later".  So to say, that there was "no choice made" is not true nor accurate?  What is true and what is accurate was.....that I didn't want to...anymore than your wife does ( and still don't many times )....and doing all those other things first is really what I want to or feel like doing, but there is more than one reason for this or WHY.  Forget about the why for now....only what I did and then .....:possibly why....I chose to do those things last...or after I did the thing that "others requested of me"....that I can trace back to one thing just to start which is the reason I think......I didn't do this the way in which your wife sounds that she does this?  I mean...what was the magic potion I drank that made me different than the rest as it appears that I am saying?  Again......this is NOT saying....I never do this or have never done this procrastinating thing.  What I an saying, is there is a choice in there somewhere or possibly.....or possibly "no choice" being made at all?  The "not intentional" part.....or  "I didn't mean it" part and this whole memory thing?  This is where it would get way too complicated for me to even say exactly the entire process going on and to a certain degree.....I am not aware of everything like this at all times, which is why it happens but there is still a choice somewhere?  I mean, we aren't Robots and just do "everything we're suppose to do"....just because?  I mean, free will exists and there's simply no denying it?  And any time free will exist...then a choice has to be made? 

And further, there are times when you have "no choice"...and you "have to do it" whether you like it or not?  I think this is where the rubber meets the road right here and I can immediately understand where and how I learned to get past this and trace that back to the source for anyone else who is interested in wanting to know "why not me?  What makes me different?"  I'm wasn't different to start with, I can assure you that, but as I think about my daily routine....my daily routine involved something that was not actually fun.....not actually anything you look forward to ( exactly )and at times.....it was the most difficult and challenging thing that I can remember ever doing?  This was...the training or conditioning that I did in swimming.  I know I keep coming back to this....but these things keep going back to the same thing and it's always swimming so that is exactly what it is and nothing more than that?  This is just the "how I did it...without knowing what I was doing" part, but in there and the why answer and then how to overcome it..l.all gets resolved in a simple explanation?  I'll pick....one of the worst ones...and walk you through it?  This is called "pure torture"....for a prolonged period of time! LOL  For every 1 or 2 minute "race" on meet day.....come 40 or 50 hours of this before hand?  Cause and effect again.......the source....and the effect......which amounts to the action at the end of it?  If you can plug......your request that  (doesn't matter what; point is, I can't do it myself).  The choice is always  ( me first )....which you cou not being 'selfless"..and being "selfish" instead?  A "selfless" act.....mean you put the other person first and put your self second?  There is a time an place for everything and a choice between the two has to be made?  And there is a thing called "free time" or "discretionary time"....when you can do anything you want to do and you can choose yourself "first".....put something off, change plans and decide to relax and take a break and put everyone else second?  As long as you aware of your choices, are conscious of your decisions and are acting "making choices"...then I think you remember those?? ( I think? ).....so what is happening the rest of the time....are you wandering aimlessly in the wilderness and just lost with no direction?  I think, in part....this may be true?  Lost in Hyper focus...will do that too you?  But "Lost in Hyper focus" is not same  as doing it with intention?  Directing that Hyper Focus on something is not just wandering aimlessly in the wilderness?  I think this very much has to do with Dissociation more than Hyperfocus and simply "removing yourself from reality"  like zoning out on TV?  Mindless, entertainment....."Alpha Wave"....."Zoning out".  When you are "In the Zone" you are definitely not "Zoning Out" and I totally Zone Out when I'm Hyperfocusing on one thing..and trying to do another?  if something is pulling me away from doing something.....it's usually for a reason and I'm resisting doing it?  It's one thing, to be doing something and working hard and needing to rest or take a break...it's another thing when you need to do that....before you even start doing it?  If you follow me here.....I bring you to "how I got past that, and trained myself to do it."   And it's called "making yourself" or "forcing yourself" to do something unpleasant.

Before I forget to metnion something here......I think it is really important to look at one thing you said within your request?  When you say ( doesn't matter what, the point is I can't do it myself ).....I think it does matter to a point, and what matters is ...are you saying you are not able to do this at the time because of other responsibilities?  Or are you saying......I can't do it...I don't not how and aI am not able to do it at all?  Not having the ability to do something that your partner can....puts you at their mercy and simply...beggars can't be chooser?  Consider that first....before you say anything else?  Best way around that one...is simply learn how to learn how to do it yourself and you will never be in that postion in the first place?  Know what I mean?  That pretty much takes care of that one, and nips that right in the bud?  You will never be at anyones mercy....if you can do it yourself?  I took care of that one....a long long time ago?  Anything I could learn to do myself, I just did so I wouldn't need to ask anyone to do it for me, it's as simple as that?  And anytime I had the chance to learn or the opportunity to learn it.....I jumped on that opportunity so I would never have to be defendant on anyone?  Deferring...only makes you dependent...and deferring is a real problem if that is the case?  That is what wife does.....but she plays both sides of the fence and that really pisses me off?  She will defer to me...what she doesn't want to do....but complain about the out come? Or what she ..can't do....and complaining about the out come there too?  If you want it done right.....do it yourself?  You can't learn how...if you don't do it in the first place?  Anyway....the other side of the fence...is not asking or not telling the other person what you are doing...and doing it it anyway, without any consultation ahead of time?  Assuming.......or  taking control......and not giving the other person the chance to say "NO".  Not giving the other person the chance or the choice to say "NO"...is actually taking their "choice" from them...which is the other side of the fence of "deferring" responsibility...and this playing both sides of the fence?  That will piss me off faster than anything else just so you know?  You aren't "clean" here if you are doing this.......gotta be "clean".....or put up and shut up?  That's the other side of the fence response to "beggars can't be choosers."  Just say'in....to keep this in mind?:  Not to say again...I don't do it.........but to reiterate....I am aware of it, and I understand it...so at least I know what I stand and where I am coming from?  If you don't know where you are and where you stand...then you are being a moving target yourself?  I think this whole idea of "no truth in the middle " comes from this very thing....but to say...that's different than being neutral...and not making a stand which might be cons...digging your heals in and becoming stubborn.....or it could be you have to...because you have no choice?  Knowing where you are.......is really what need to happen first I think?  If someone takes your choices from you...then sometimes you have to make a stand?  There is no choice...when you have no other options ( or choices )  Free will, choices, responsibility and deferring....are you clean or not clean...and and you playing both sides of the fence.  And can you even do it ( at all)?  Or are you at the mercy of someone else?  All of this...plays into it...and it all matters that's for sure.

Okay....lots of stuff here but getting to the how part for me?  This is exactly where if came from...... worst worst case scenario:       20 x 200yard Freestyle....on the 3 minutes.  YIKES!  Yes indeed.....60 minutes of non stop torment and pain!! LOL  Her's how that one worked.  The faster you go...of course at the end of  the 200yards...the more rest you get and typically....at first, you get about 45 seconds or so? ( as I remember? )  But after the first 2 or so...now you start to get tired...so it takes more energy to go the same distance and the slower you become.  And the slower you become.....the less rest you get.  And the less rest you get, the harder and more difficult it becomes, which means "Pain" and "exhaustion" and it only gets worse not better, with each one you do?  This is a "no win scenario" and there is no escape from the pain.  House of pain....is what you call this....once you enter, there is no way out?  It is inversely correlated to comfort!!!  With intention! LOL  By the time you make these choices and the only choice you have is to simply survive....there is no win or no prize in this exercise.  Do not attempt to adjust your TV set....we have control of the vertical, we have control of the horizontal...for the next 60 minutes ...you have entered the Outer Limits of Pain!! LOL

What I remember most about this which sticks in your memory (clearly)...is that you automatically settle in to a pace you can endure?  And to the point....that you try everything first?  First you slow down to conserve energy....but then when you reach the end...you've got like 10 seconds to rest...and that's not enough rest to recover ( barely )..so now the next one is worse than the previous one...ahhhhhhh!!! .  So the next one, you go alittle faster and it hurts more, but you get more rest and you recover more before you start.  So this trade off back and forth between  pain while your doing it..and how much rest you get at the end becomes clear.  The most valuable commodity and the only variable that is worth any thing is time.  All you care about..and all you focus on..is how much rest you will get.  Every second of rest....is a very valuable thing?  In this case....time = money...does not apply.....time = "reief from pain"  and you will do anything to get it...any way you can?  And there is only one way to get it, and that is to swim faster..and the faster you go, the more it hurts while you are doing it?  But the way you do it...is to be steady and consistent and find the magic line.  Too much while your doing it....you can't make to the end the hour.  Too little...and suffer while your doing it more, since you don't have enough chance to recover and rest?  There is a majic line in there somewhere, but there is only one way to get to that line.  Go through the wall of pain....and make it to that line.  That line lives on the other side of comfort, so if your in the House of Pain....you get use to it, and you live in it and live there for a while.  Once you find that sweet spot of just enough but not too much.....you learn how to pace yourself and it simply a self fulfilling thing.  It's 1 to 1 relationship..the more you give...the more you get?  And the entire time your doing this...your thinking of only one thing....the prize at the end on race day...that 1 or 2 minutes that really count.  It's delayed gratification, and a direct connection to the source.  1 to 1 relationship with the pay off at the end.  You have to give to get...and you get when the work is done?

What I remember most of all in this in this....is looking up at the big time clock on the wall...and watching every second tick by, before I had to go again.  And looking at the minute hand, and checking how much more I had to endure this for.  I can tell you under those circumstances......you learn just how important and valuable..10  seconds can be.  You also learn, just how little rest you really need to recover and to survive.  More than anything else..the House of Pain teaches you the value of time.  Absolutely more than anything else, that's what it teaches you.

From that.....I can't really give you any direct advise how to learn that.....but the value of time and delayed gratification...is the lesson that needs to be learned.  That..and you have to give to get.....all came from swimming with me...but I guess that's the bottom line?  It's why I tend to do things first ....then I take my breaks and my rest but not always....depends on different things but the fact that I am aware of all of this..and  when I make the wrong choice, it was a choice and I just screwed up  and I will say so if its true because it is....you won't get all that double taking or defending and denying simple because I know it is true. Do it again differently next time, until you find that magic line .Once your in the house of pain..there's no excuses and no free lunch.

J

I just wanted to share this for what it's worth because this is so "me". LOL   In all the years I did those swims and workouts and even later as a coach ( this is so typical of me ) and I don't know exactly what this shows or means but I still thinks it's funny as I just did this for the very 1rst time ever? LOL  I never stopped to add up just how far that 20 x 200yd "swim set" actually was?  It's 4,000 yards which I always knew cause that's how we tallied the workout totals?  But 4,000yds doing the math is 2.27 miles.  In one hour.  No wonder it hurt so much!!!!  The fact is however......the workouts were 1hour 45 minutes so that was not the only thing we did?  But whose counting I guess? LOL  I sure didn't????? Obviously. lol

This reminds of that song "know when to hold em.....know when to fold em......but never count your cards while you're sitting at the table....there'll be counting time when the dealing is done." LOL  takes longer for some of us I guess? LOL  Why I was laughing.

J

I don't have any exact answers here, but I can provide my own experience as a base line?  I saw my T for nearly 5 years, before I was the one who brought up the possibility of ADHD after reading more on the subject?  Obviously, he had been doing "some kind of thereapy with me" the entire time, but I am not exactly sure which one that is?  I've asked, and he's said he uses a number of different strategies combined and tailored individually to each person which was his answer?  Okay....what ever he was doing, was working and helping me a lot?  I knew that, or I wouldn;t have continued seeing him?

And when I did mention the ADHD possibility to him, he said he mentioned it, and I immediately said " You did?"....which he said, "well, you and ( my ex ) were pretty deep into a lot of other issues you had going, so that was not your focus or ( our ) focus at the time?  Now ( paraphrasing him ) "you are more focused on you" ?  Which is all true, but just mentioning ADHD in passing did not register at the time fo the very reason he was saying?

So then....I starting asking him question and specifically, about medication which was when he sent me to someone who could prescribe with his recomendation.  That's when I took the tests she provided and asked me for my own self assesment to go along with it?  My first prescriber was rather cautious as she told me.....that in all the years she had done that ( more than 30 years ) that she only had two people trying to convince here they had ADHD just to get on the meds themselves so she appeared to be aware of that possibility?  With me, and with my T recommendation....it seemed everything lined up and she went no further with me in sending me in for further testing and evaluation? And I specifically didn't want to go the stimulant route first, and try the alternatives which really didn't work for me at all?

So finally...after 5 years and trying everything else first, she prescribed the Adderall along with "Prozac" both....and I started on this journey of medication and getting everything to work.  I was on the Prozac for a year, and I finally stopped taking it just see if there was much of a difference as I felt kind of flat...and unemotional at the time?  Like..."too much" emotion was being taken out and I didn't know which drug was causing this exactly?  I figured by eliminating one....I could at least see what one did without the other?  The Prozac appeared to not do much except give me that "flat...lifeless feeling" and took out too much of the highs and lows...so I discontinued use which made me feel more like myself again....but now with the added benefit of the Adderall which made an immediate impact....like right away, that I could tell really helped which felt like suddenly seeing things I had never seen before and gave me abilities I never had?  That was kind of her criteria too as I would describe this as it happened which was the most confirming thing to her as time went on?  It appeared that it was working as it should...so if it's not broken, why fix it?   Near sightedness....seemed to be the issue all along and the Adderall fixed that one...with amazing results.

And recently here, the article provided a while back, that suggests that men tend to compartmentalize more than women...seemed to make sense but also gave me pause to thin about this in terms of "compartmentalzing gone hay wire" or to the extreme?  I think....that "near sightedness" exacerbates somewhat normal compartmentalizing into more extreme compartmentalizing but thinking along these lines.....I'm not sure where to draw any lines and say what is what?

For example....when I was at work for my last employer.....I had to adopt his program and his way of thinking into mine?  I had to separate what "I thought was right or wrong" and follow what he wanted instead?  What I thought or felt was best, right, wrong or even good for the company....was not up to me to decide?  I had to take my own feelings and thoughts "out side of work" and put them somewhere else?  As soon as I walked in the door.....I took on "his way" and spoke for him...as he directed me to do?  I did what I was told...and I didn't ask questions.  Even if I felt it was sketchy....or thought it was a bad idea?  I followed order...even if I thought is was wrong which is my understanding ( in part )  as a form of compartmentalizing but with full awareness of it.

What I ran across with my oldest sister and even my wife is somewhat different than that?  I mentioned the possibility of ADHD with her, since she was the one who had said that she saw "in my Mom, and in me...some similar things?  As she said...."Your just lkke Mom......which at first I took offense at but then asked what it was that was the same?  When she described what was the same ( as she saw it )...that made a lot more sense to me since it was the ADHD qualties and yes, in a number of ways....I could see that easily which is not exactly the same as saying "your just like mom"  I was about to really have a problem with this since I am so much....not like my Mom in most ways..l except for the ones she mentioned which I confirmed to her "well yes.....that's the ADHD"  But when I mentioned the ADHD....but also shared with her how "myself" and her...were so much different since I am an extrovert and she is an introvert and I gave her the same explanation I learned from my T which she immediately started saying..."well that sounds like me? "
Later....she told me she had read a book on "introverts" that I can't remember the name of....but then said "and that was really good for me to read since I definitely am an introvert and I understand that now....but I'm good with that, I don't need to go any further from there?  Which was her saying......I don't want to go down the ADHD road....."I'm good with introvert and I'm comfortable with that."  I think that is a different kind of compartmentalizing than what I described?

And what I see and saw with my wife is the very same thing?  I brought up a number of possibilities to my wife about "herself" including: ADHD, Bi-Polar, PTSD and even the avoidant attachment...as well as OCD and perfectionsim and pretty much everything I've learned with her?  Even her friend with ADHD....told her she wouldn't be surprised if she had ADHD so I know of at least one other person who passed that along to her?

The one...and only "item" on the list...that she jumped on and accepted....was PTSD and she has no problem talking about or accepting that much even to this day?  Like my sister....she too the "one" that was most acceptable or palatable and put the others away or dismissed them completely?

What really took me back right at first....and still to this day, I don't know exactly what my T is doing.....but as soon as my wife started joining us with the 3 of us in the room.....what ever he is doing or has been doing with my wife....it a completely different method or way he is with her...compared to me?  He was speaking to me, in almost code....and that is and was very frustrating since I was willing to discuss anything about me with "them in the room"....but he was not allowing me to say what was on my mind with my wife in the room?  Suddenly.....were in a different program...or method than the one he used with me?   I mean....the entire program had completely changed to one I did not ( and still do not know ) what you call it or what that is?  I could no longer speak openly with him ( for the very first time even with my ex in comparison ) but I quickly got from this and how it was different...was what was NOT being said?

As I learned the hard way and in context to what was happening, my T knew what i didn't know until I finally understood why that was myself

So basically with me.....I never really wanted to know exactly what he was doing....all I knew was that it working and that's all I cared about?

And my experience with my other sister when my Mom was dying...was beyond frustrating to me....since she was saying thing and speaking to my Mom...from a perspective that I knew myself...but only from what my mother had told me....which went right back to "her mother" as I heard those words again?  As she was telling my mother as she was speaking to her...."that your going to see ( the list of dead relatives ) who are waiting for her in Heaven"

Okay...this is not to criticize or say that what ever you believe is not right ...right or wrong.....this is to say...."these words were what mky mom told me when I was a little boy word for word.  And those words...were my Grandmothers words....word for word exactly as I remembered it?  To me...this was very telling since I had questioned my mothers about this at length when I was younger and didn't get any real hard answers from her so I finally gave up trying?  Back to getting kicked out of Sunday school...so I new better than that?

But ...before my sister arrived and just took over the entire process....I was sitting there alone with my mom and hospice nurse....and simply trying to comfort my my by saying "I'm here with you now.....if you need to go, it's Okay"

That's a pretty stark contrast between...."your mom and dad and sister are all waiting for you up in heaven"....and kind of weird thing to say to a dying person who is unconscious at the time?

My other sister....was not doing that either and she was more just being present with her too but without doing what I was doing and trying to think of what my mom needed to here.....if I was there dying?  Not to be alone...was all I came up with?  Seemed like the thing to say and what would be pertinent...to me that was....if I was still here?   Telling me that "every ones waiting for you"  kind of would have made me feel, it's more about the people waiting than it would be about what I was really feeling in the moment od dying?  That would have pissed me off.....as it did when my sister said that?

The confirming moment for me there....was when the nurse came to me later...and told me that was one of the most moving things she had seen in all the time she had been dong that job....so from an outside observation....I think that was the best course in that case to take.  My sister....seemed to be off in her own world in her head....but ironically, it was the same one that my mother herself had told us?

And I have to share this here, because i still think it's really kind of funny ( which may be along the same lines of this discussion ) so I thought I would just share what I was actually thinking when my sister burst into the room and found me alone with my mom and started talking about Heaven and who she was going to meet there?  I could not get...this episode of "Curb Your Enthusiasm" out of my head...when Larry actually dies and goes to Heaven...to find Moses waiting for him there?  And while he was getting the tour of Heaven....he spots Ben Hogan up there and immediately asks Moses...if he can meet him and of course he could?  So when he's talking to Ben Hogan...he finds out that Heaven as a complete 18 hole golf course and Ben tells him that when he gets settled...that he should come play a round on the links with him? LOL   And Larry is just ecstatic about being there and is completely blown away about the prospect of playing gold with Ben Hogan, and he's just beside himself with joy and anticipation?  And right then, is when Larry gets called back to earth, since the doctors resuscitated him in his hospital bed....and he's screaming NO NO....I don't want to go back!! And  I think Ben Hogan tells him, the golf round will just have to wait until he makes it back at a later date.  LOL

And that is what i couldn't get out of my head...the entire time my sister was telling my mom about all the people she was going to meet but as usual....I just kept my mouth shut? LOL  Better than being angry I guess....but it was the first thing that popped into my head as I clearly remember that moment and going "errrrrrrrr"  My conection time with my mom....had just been interupted with images of Larry David talking to Ben Hogan up in the Heaven...while ( Moses ) played by Dustin Hoffman..was setting up their T time? LOL  Sorry....that is the honest to God truth right there? LOL  What can I say?

So from my perspective.....I really don't know ( or still don't know ) where this compartmentlzing things goes hay wire?  All my T told me and again, just summarizing...that "everything has it's place"...kind of like an old fashioned switch board operator and mail sorter who is soring the mail...and putting each piece in the appropriate slot ( picture a large wall full of square slots...and the sorter is organzing them by address?  But as she said this....he explained that if something doesn't have an exact address or there is no slot to put it into.....subconsiously....this will not do....so "it has to go into one of the slots already there"....so "you" or what ever it si that is being sorted, goes in the closest one...or the closest slot...even if it's not the right one and actually doesn't fit any of them?

In other words.......if something doesn't have a slot....or it's not something you understand or have seen before......it MUST.....go in a slot!!  And so it goes into one of these mail slots.....even it really doesn't fit or belong with the rest of the mail that's there?  Even if it doesn't fit or even if it really doesn't beling in any of the slots that are available.....you can't have loose mail lying around without a slot.  This simply won't do and must go into a slot of some kind, so it goes into the nearest one closest you can find?

I know I do this....I just don't know if what I do, is the same as everyone else?

J

 

Never go to a counselor w/ a person in denial....It just turns into frustration and wasted money for you....A counselor can be a good thing IF (Big IF) a person wants help...When a spouse or close friend takes it on themselves to push their mate to be aware.... It Only ends bad for the pusher.....:)

C

As I have said before....I was the one who sought counseling after my divorce and wanted to continue since I felt like I was getting so much out of it, while my ex wife seemed to get nothing out of it at all?  People have issues outside of ADHD ( which are attachment related ) which was when I started learning about Attachment Theory with my ex wife ( way before ADHD was part of the conversation ) Regardless, I've been with the same one for years and now with two different people which is kind of weird in one way ( however )....no one has complained about my T specifically ...although the mention that "it's really not helping" has come up in both cases?

My thoughts about this resonate with what you said.  A person who is going to therapy....thinking the "therapists" is going to somehow magically fix this problem  ( a person who refuses to take responsibility as he's mentioned and remain a victim  (to their issues) and is in denial.....(yes, both go with the same territory and is a big red flag in a general pattern )  are not going to suddenly change how they see things which means having to do the "work" as they say means....looking at yourself and like your name sake or handle here says  "cure yourself"....means, looking at the things that are not so pleasant or fun to look at ( in yourself...not the other person )...which is what therapy is all about?  No matter if it's alone...or with another person.....it's all about looking at yourself and seeing what you are doing wrong?  I mean, what would you think without thinking anything else?  ( it ain't gonna suck itself you know? )....sorry, a less than polite company phrase that hits the bulls eye better than anything esle I can think of?  You can do with that as you will.....but the meaning is what is most important?  That's the meaning that somehow does not translate with a person who is in denial ....as it appears?  They think....somehow by magic....."it's gonna suck itself" which means they are waiting for the other person to do something?

That was the mind boggling frustrating part of trying to do any exercises or anything with my wife what so ever and now I just look at it and just shake my head?  I mean, to the point of being ridiculous which I think is the "kind of compartmentalization" that I was trying to differentiate from what might be considered normal?  I mean, I compartmentalize all the time....but that is not the kind that goes with denial as a defense mechanism which is astounding, baffling, frustrating and down right maddening ( crazy making ) when a person employs it to "block" what they don't want to or can't look at?   I mean...to watch this in action ( or experience it in real time ) is the part that makes you almost lose your mind it's so exasperating?

One of the most telling examples of this that I can think of was watching this video on FaceBook of an interview that took place in a senate appropriations committee hearing?  Forget about the topic, it's irrelevant to what I'm saying.  The most poignant take away from this video was what the "interviewer said" and how he responded?  As he said" "I didn't walk in her with my hair on fire.....but I'm walking out of here with it!!  I have never ( and I means in10 years ) run up against anything like it in the all time I've been doing this?  This is totally unacceptable!!!  That's you answer????"

And the interviewee said "Yes, that's my answer"

That was a real defining moment for me going...."this is it.....and it's never going to change unless she changes it?"  This is what my life will be like in 10 years....just like this interview?  It definitely takes two and with 3 you get eggroll.  With denial and no awareness.....all you get is a poke in the eye with a blunt stick each and every time to you attempt to communicate or even try and talk about anything with someone like this?  Just like this......until "they change".  And you can't do it for them, you can only change yourself.

Compartmentalization gone horribly wrong.  My blood pressure went up just watching this video!!! LOL ( Yikes!!! )  I definitely felt the interviewers pain!  But it doesn't stop there.  The "poking continues" INCESSENTLY!!  poke ,poke, poke, poke until ( I ) blow my Top!  It's like the Hornets nest is already buzzing with a lot of agitated "bees" upstairs.......but when my hair burst into flames and Hornets nest just got one too many rocks thrown at it, it's all I can do to keep my shit togeter and just so I don't lose it all over the place? 

Fix'in to git a might bit riled up and then some!!!  It takes all the energy I got in me....not to blow my lid and lose my mind at times in the face of this exact same thing?  The added poking is just the cherry on top or the straw that breaks the Camels back?  ( sheese )  It's like she has no idea she does this and her brother does the same thing in the same way which I've tried to explain to her at times but I understand....explaining it to her is like talking to a brick wall?  It doesn't nothing to stop it and it just keeps comiing?

You can only "fix it".....if you can see it, just like you can only draw it if you see it?  If you can't see it.....then you can't fix it?  That's what denial does for you.....it keeps it buried in your subconscious but it is definitely there?  Compartmentalization without awareness....and as part of the dissociation that takes place means it's got to go somewhere....and where it goes in all over you? ( the other person )  Even if they have no idea what they are doing, what they are doing feels like the neighbor dog coming into your yard to do his bussiness everyday and then goes back to his own yard where he doesn't have to deal with his own shit?  That's exactly what it feels like.....getting "dumped on" constantly....one "pooh" at a time!!! poke, poke poke poke.....it simply never stops!!

This, I can say with a fair amount of certainty.  I may have my ways and my means to complain and vent and all things negative ( and criticize, and mock and be sarcastic and the whole nine yards )  But.....I am very aware of what I'm doing, what I am saying ( at least the impulse and what actually gets said ) and even if I might say something "sharp" or "pointed"....it is usually in direct relationship with something being said or happening in the moment when I say it?  There is a direct link...to the words that come out of my mouth....in direct relationship to what is happening at the time?  Not about the past.....but directly in relationship to "right now this minute" and I can remember exactly what I said and why I said it if someone were to aks me?  I know what AI am feeling.....and I know WHY......I am feelking it...and if someones asks me a straight forward question.....I know the answer and I know why I feel the way I do? 

What I definitely do not do ( without question and without hesitation )....is go around "poking people" for no reason, and if I do, I have a reason and I can say so up front?  I definitely do not go looking for trouble and try an avoid conflict as best I can?  My wife is like a conflict magnet......she "has to poke"......to get rid of any uncomfortable feelings or to "send a message" everywhere she goes?  These are so trivial and so petty...they are hardly worth mentioning....but if someone walked up to you and started "poking you in the arm" with the tip of their finger......after about 500 of those in the same spot...over and over ( none stop ) again and again....and you tell them to knock it off...and then 2 minutes later within telling them to stop it....they do it again? I don't know about you, but all I want to do is grab that finger, and break it in two...and then say "try that one more time.....and see what happens!!!"   errrrrrrrrrr!  Poke poke poke poke poke......snap!!!  You only have to tell me once to stop ( what ever ) and I will actully rmemeber and do my best not to do it?  Unless I am just venting which I know when I'm doing that for most part even if it leals out in a negative way?  But I never look at someones food that just arrived on the table.,..and before the person has a chance to take the first bite ( of their food....not mine ) and say "that's looks aweful.....that looks like it's undercooked, or I hate spaghetti anyway...it makes me want to puke ...or point out of something "wrong"....with "my food"....just before I take a bite? Like...WTF??

First....it's not "your food" and "you" don't have to eat it?
Second.....what does it matter that "you" don't like Spaghetti?  I like it, or I wouldn't have ordered it?  Do you have some kind problem with me eating "Spaghetti"...or you have a problem with having to look at it?  Which one is it?
Third........what business is it of yours anyway?  That's not a rhetorical question?

Fourth........WHO CARES if you don't like Spaghetti?  I mean really?  Who cares that much about what you think?  I really don't need your opinion of my Spaghetti...and I also don't appreciate you "taking a dump" right in the middle of my plate, before I even take the first bite?  What are you trying to do here?  Ruin my enjoyment and my enjoying my meal....by taking a huge dump in the middle of my Spaghetti because "YOU" don't like Spaghetti?  Why would you do that?  What are you trying to say here?  What message are you sending and why?  Huh?  That is not a rhetorical question?   poke poke poke!!!

click.......errrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr    There you go.....and it never stops no matter how many times you  bring it up?  ( poke poke poke poke ) everywhere she goes?  It is just petty and unimportant....but after the 5000th time......it gets more than just old?  With me, I about lose my shit after that much time, and sometimes I have....just like this guy in the video.  Not just kind of "like it"......"exactly like it".....non stop and just keeps on happening day after day and never stops.   The difference between "denial"...and "not in denial" ...I guess?  One is outside of your awareness...and the other is inside of it...even if you do it and it comes out...you know you did it..and you also know why?  One is a choise....the other is without choice, unintentional and completely unaware?  What is needed is a wake up call......to wake up and smell the bacon in this case I guess?

Just like this guy in the video except in the case...it did not include the interviewee.....following afte the interviewer and keep repeating the same thing as the guy is trying to get away from him?  This video didn't include the "poking the Hornets nest"...right after the guys hair was set on fire!!! LOL First you light the Hornets nest on fire....then you throw rocks at it?  ( not the wisest thing to do in my thinking? LOL )  Nothing like adding insult to injury?  Maybe that's where they coined that phrase?? LOL  But the most exaperating part of all is when you stand there and tell them what they just did...and they get mad at you and say  "no I didn't....that's what you just did"    It's enough to make you lose you mind!! LOL  And then some.

C....that's the part I agree with you on and why therapy won't do anything very effectively to stop this or make this change unless they want to go for themselves....not thinking it's exclusively for your partner to change( only)?

  The only part I won't agree with but you really didn't mention this either....is that I got a lot out of going to therapy with my wife.....even if she didn't?  I had an unfair advantage and a  big head start....but none the less, what I learned from my T in this case....was what to do and why you do it....when confronted with someone like this?  At least for me.....I learned why that a person like this is just not a good fit for me.....even if I can live with them....they certainly cannot live with me but to the point....they will not leave it or you alone.  ( poke poke poke poke )  That will drive you mad....after the 10,000th time.  Not for one minute do I not know why on my end.....I'm just saying....I do not do that....I can take it or leave it and I can deal and cope with things on my own and not have to 'take it out on" other people as a rule?  Unless they are in my face that is.....in the moment, not about the past? ( except the poking) and going around taking a dump....on my food just before I eat it?  Or the many other variations in the hundreds of different ways this comes out everywhere, all the time, non stop?  Kicking the dog....it exactly what it is?  That's a deal breaker for me........that is totally unacceptable. ( with extreme predudice and contempt ) That is simply no good.  Unless your intention is to rile that person up or shake things up to get peoples attention or use in a politcal debate?  That';s different and for a different reason?   But no one wants to live at a political ralley 24/7.....with a member of the opposing party for a room mate of spouse?  Know what I mean? ( sheese )  And of course....my wife contends she is not this way and will say so which is not true...but she simply in denial of it and actually believes it which is different than lying with the intention to deceive?  That, she really hasn't done as far as I can tell but it is hard to tell sometimes?  Mostly...the results of her actions shows she is more unaware than aware...but there is no way for me to tell exactly and what parts she is..and which parts she isn't.  The poking...she simply has no awareness of while she is doing it....but you can't tell her she is doing it....or she will blow a gasket., which is why she stays in denial so she won't have to look at it....I can tell that much for sure.  This is a closed topic for discussion...she has made that perfectly clear.

https://www.facebook.com/NowThisPolitics/videos/1625474017484082/

J

PS....Before I completely neglect to say......the therapy I got out of being here and participating as well as far as what I learned in conjunction with everything else?  That you might say is "priceless" to be direct and right to the point?  No way I can even put a value on that, and simply the opportunity to do so?  What more can I say other than you simply have no idea  .( other than Thank you.....one more time ;)

I guess this is a follow up to me, actually putting everything in it's place and looking past this ( puzzle) that I have been trying to solve ( or get to an answer ) that at least, satisfies my enough to know what I am seeing and then know what I'm going to do about it?  I've read through the comments here again and they really are helpful to me in that I recognize the things being said and that really is validating?  What I'm saying is I recognize these things in myself and just where I stand?  Maybe I can just speak to what I know about myself now with a pretty firm conviction that I know enough, to know that even if I'm not 100% correct about everything.....I am in the ball park and the rest I can worry about as it comes.....knowing what I know?

So how do I know what I know?  Well, I know everything I use to think,  and I know everything that I feel about those things....and then I know everything I've learned after the fact ( in the retrospect ) and I know that too?  Now it is just a matter of seeing where the differences between these two meet, and trying to fit myself into the new picture?  It really is like a jig saw puzzle...where each new piece you fit that fits, you get to see more of the picture?  I think what I'm saying here is and maybe it's somewhat the same in my own way of seeing it......that there is an existential or esoteric ( feeling of somethings wrong ) that is not going to go away or be resoved until you can see what it is? 

Actually, what is true as I have found....that the feeling doesn't go away....but it changes from what it was, and that comes from solving the jig saw puzzle and finding where all the pieces fit?  And as far as letting go or knowing when to "stop solving?"  You know that when you see "enough" of the jig saw puzzle to see what that picture or image is?  You don't have to keep doing the puzzle just to finish it....that isn't the goal?  The goal is just to see enough of the picture to actually know what it is?  If you still have a few pieces left and some of the corners or spots left unfinished.....you can still see this beautiful scene of a water mill and an old Mill house on a Mill creek with a big Willow Tree next to it and a boy in a row boat paddlling along on a nice sunny day? 

I mean, if part of the Willow Tree is left unfinished....undoubtedly even if you see all those left over peices with green leaves on them lying on the table....that picture is not going to change much aside from simply being fully complete with no peices on the table?  Like I said...it's not about finishing the picture completely....it's just about being able to see the "scene" in it's entirety....and that is when it's time to stop I think?  You've seen enough...to "get the picture" or say....."I get it" and that's really the truth right there?

And of course....that's my picture I'm talking about?  If I don't have my "picture" fully in view.....then when you add someone elses picture to mine.....then it makes it difficutl to get the picture of the two of you together and this is where the co-dependency starts seeping in?  Without a clear image of what that picture looks like....those ( unfinished areas ) the jig saw puzzle....are left completely blank meaning...those big areas of the puzzle left unfinished..,..need some more pieces fit into it, to at least get an idea of what you are seeing? 

And without those peices available ( or answers from the other person )......you do end up just like the senator in the commitee hearing with your hair on fire?  Like he said, "I have NEVER run into anything like this, in all the time I've been doing this.....all I want is some God Damned answers.....and YOU REFUSE to give them to me!!!!  Unbeleivable!! "

Why I come back there is important to understand from my perspective.  I have been struggling with something the entire time I have been here in fact, it is the reason ( mainly ) that I have come to understand that is "REAL"....meaning "reality".  I struggle with or have problems with "non-reality" or can I say "partial reality" which means the "incomplete picture" and I suspect that is ( possibly ) not what others without ADHD struggle with and I think my suspiciouns are correct?  I cannot know that, I just suspect that it which by default, I simply say "yes" this is most likely the case?  I'm different than evreryone else in this way, so I've got to dig deeper and find these things out so I know what to do with it and know how to manage that situation better?  In other words, I need more of the picture and I need to know more than I am getting since this is not enough to do what I know I can do?

The video of the Senator was not staged or an act.  That was a real life drama happening and everything was authentic and very real?  It wasn't scripted and his reactions ( as a human being ) were recognizable to me.  I knew how he felt, and I knew why he felt that way?  In fact, I new exactly why he felt that way since I feel that way all the time.  It is a very familiar feeling and wanting to know out of curiousity is not what that was all about?  As he said, "we have a crisis going on, and if we are going to do anything to "fix it"...I need the simply answers ...answered, so I can do something about it?  Some kind of action is required, and I can;t do anything until you answer the questions and fill in the "blanks" of this puzzle?  This particular "crisis" puzzle that I need those peices "first" so I can fix it? 

And ..."All I want is some God Damned answers....and you REFUSE TO GIVE THEM TO ME!!!"   But as I understand and know now....that's not the problem here with much of what we're talking about?  It is not a conscious or deliberate Refusal.....that is already going down the wrong road in this case.   And this gets right down to the the question of WHY?   For the Senator, the answer or solution is clear.  When he gets those answers, then he can fix the problem or at least, set about the task of making it right with a plan or action and some kind of remedy.  Problem solved?  Not so much as to what we are talking about....."problem solved" is knowing the "WHY" first.....which means in terms of denail......that person doesn't know WHY....and they have no idea and they simply don't know, so they "can't answer the questions".  It is not a refusal as much as something else preventing this from happening and that is the "WHY"....and the jig saw puzzle that needs to be completed (first) before you can go any further?

So what is the base line between a non-ADHD person and an ADHD person?  What is the common ground that "both" can see and use to come to an understanding?  "Reality".....it is that simply and that difficult all at the same time?  And since everyone seems to have a different reality based on them and all the differences and the reasons why.....then what is "real" and what is "illusion" and what is the base line here for every human being on the planet?  The "reality" that everyone shares, no matter who you are?  What does that picture look like...and what is "real" or "not real"?  I can answer that with what I know.  What I know is....I have my own reality and I can see that clearly....and ....I have come to learn how to see the other realities their are...and see where the common ground is?  And I can see the differences which tells me where I am different than everyone else and that right there is the big picture  ( not just my puzzle ) but mine and everyones....to the level I am able?

What I have discovered which is a remarkable thing.....is that I really can see things at times that others don't always see or they miss ( or they can't ) and that can be a beautiful thing?  It can also be as frustrating as all get out...when you can see something that ( apparently?? ) no one else can see....or at least, fewer people than most...which can be very disheartening?  And this internet thing  ( this artificial reality ) really messes me up?  Same with simply talking on the phone or communicating just by writing?  Without that person there....standing right in front of me....I have a hard time operating ( as I would normally ) without all that information missing?  As my T has suggested in speaking about his as "just a slice of the pie" not the "whole pie" which is reality?  This is the same problem ( as I see it ) with Porn or even masterbating.  Fiction, fantacy, imagination and "virtual anything" including "virtual sex" via porn....is not real......but it is  as my T has said  " a slice of the pie".  This, I have so clearly defined in my mind that I cannot see how anyone else cannot see this?  It is beyond obvious to me...so I might assume everyone else see's it this way?  In the same respect....is it enough to feel satisfied and the answer is no...it's not enough, but it's better than nothing you might say?  Do you have to have it ....can you live without?  That is a good question.....but of course the answer is yes?  The answer is yes....but now where does that leave you?  Can you be Okay without it......or...."as good"...with nothing?

This is the same thing I discovered by going on FaceBook.  FaceBook is no different than Porn in the same way?  It leaves you wanting more....since it is not enough.  It is just a "slice of the pie" and is not "real".  Whithin the "slice of the pie" that it is.....that is very real.  But is it enough to meet your needs...and be satisfied?  For me the answer is simply no.  And the reason for that is very easy for me to answer......the way I function and the way I operate best, is "live in person" due to both my strengths and limitations.  The limitations come from "needing to be live and in person"....but when I am is where all my "strengths" kick in?  Without the "reality" and the "real person" there to gather all thyat missing energy and all the millions or sublte physcial cues happening that my radar and my senses are all designed to recieve....."words" alone can't give me that or replace it for me?  There is a giganitic hole in my ability to read and understand without that "tons" of info that I get, from being "live" in person?  I need very few words, in that case since I can get a "sense" from them....and I know what that means?  It tells me a great deal, without anything being said?  And I didn't have to have anyone teach or tell me how to do that?  It just happens all on it's own and I really didn't need to know why to know what I know but without any ability to explain it or say...."how I know?"  The same with animals too.  I have always been able to sense, what they are feeling and from that I can act or do accordingly since they cannot "talk" or "tell you" these things?  And they seem to understand or know when you do this?  Somehow, they know, that you know and they relate to you and you with them and no one is saying much of anything?  Animals do this and so do people (I think? ).  All I know is, I do it and I don't know how exactly....but I know exactly what I know, and this is what I know?  And I know, I have always been able to do this going back as far as I can remember?  It is like reading "brail' I guess?  Either you can read "brail" of you can't?  And if you can't read brail, then you won;t know what the message is written to know what it is saying?  This is most frustrating and really aggrivating!! LOL  I can read "people" way.....and they can't seem to "get it" the same way I can?  But.....take my ability away from me..and put me in this artificual contructed world of the inter net....and bam......I'm left without my abilities anymore...and now all I got is just words?  Highly frustrating....to say the least!! LOL  It is very difficult, to ge the same sense.....from only "a slice of the pie"?  All that does, is kind od leaves me flat....like I just got dropped off on the side of the road...and left there standing there frustrated at times?  It's like I needed a ride all the way into town....and the driver just pulled over out of the blue and told me to get out? LOL That is exactly what it feels like and I'm going, "Okay then.....I guess I need to hitch hike the rest of the way and catch another ride?" LOL  And apparently, what is good enough for some....is not good enouhg for others and this is what I thinking or feeling as to why I never pursued the "inter net" and this new techonology thing?  That includes the smart phones and all these gadgets....that are "created intelligence" or "AI" which I don't care which way you sloice it....it's still mising something very reall...and very muchy needed to get the picture or the entire "Pie of understanding"?  And this is what makes people move away sometimes including my wife there for sure?  It's the fact that I penetrate ( kind of intensly.ya think ? lol ) but only when I need to know more and I need more information?  That is...to get the whole pie of understanding which I am fully aware that I do this?  In person, however......I don't need to do this?  In person....I get all that info...and I can work from my senses just fine.  My senses have almost never failed me since they are all based in "reality"...."like energy" happening...right now?  All I remember ( in a humourous way ) when I was little was hearing ( constantly )...."don't touch that" LOL.  "Why not?"...as I would always say?

Well, I know now why not, since it pisses people off!! LOL  It really makes people nervous, when you go around toching everything!!! LOL  But the fact is....it is how I learn?  Tactile, and visually...is how I learn things?  I get from that, a great deal of information...that there is no way to get....in an "artificial world" or the "reality" or the "internet"...."the virtual slice of the pie".  I need to "touch it...hold it, and feel it" in order to understand it....it's really that simple?  Simple for me....unlike trying to do it another way which is where all my challenges come in?  More information is needed.....to get what I am not getting to see the entire puzzle "enough" to call it good?  That's really all I need....just enough of the picture to tell me what it is?

I'm sorry for making this a long post....but I am going somewhere with all of this.  I just read this the other day and more and more light and understanding came from this...from having that puzzle picture enough to see exactly where I stand here?

I can say this now better than I have before.....what is almost more frustrating...is know too much than not knowing or knowing to little?  If I am "ADHD"....then that is who I am or what I have?  What no one knows and there is no way to know....is just how much I know...and just how much I aware of?  The symptoms really tell you nothing more...than the slice of the pie.  That is all you see...so the "whole rest of the pie" is missing  or unknown?  Maybe what you see is what you get?  And maybe there is lot more in there or that I am completely aware of....and not being given credit for?  Maybe...I know a lot and in fact....maybe I know things other people don't know which is more to the truth than anyhting else?  I am way more than the slice....and then some but that came from a lifetim of learning so I am right where I am?  Nothing more...but nothing less?  That is reality.....and that really is what I need more than anything else?  And I just want straight answers .....from straight questions and nothing more?

This is that thing that really really hits up against this things my wife does that does make me crazy?  She asks questions.....to tell you something?  errrrrrrrr!!!  Like in code....it drives me batty!!  Really.  She asks or poses questions....when she doesn't want an answer?  She asks questions....when she is trying to tell you something which to me is completely ass backwards?  Why...on earth...,would you "ask a question"....and that is actually "telling you anything?" LOL  Or better...as a method or means to tell you something?  I mean crap.....if I know what it is.....then I wouldn't ask the question? Why would you ask a question....and not want to know the answer?  And if you know the answer...then why would you ask the question?  I mean....lets not make this more difficult than it needs to be?  If you know the damn answer...then spit it out!!! LOL ( as I see it ) which is part of our communication problem which makes no sense to me at times?  And then when she asks and I answer her....she stop me and say...."sometimes I just want to be heard? "  I get that.....so why are you asking me questions and being heard at the same time if you don't want the answer?  As I have also come to learn...that "can we talk"....means.....she talks...I listen...there is not talking on my account wanted or needed? LOL  In both respects......me talking or answering....is neither wanted or appreciated! LOL  ( which is frustrating as Hell!! ) LOL

Here's what I read...speaking about diagnosis, therapy and attachment.  And just to be clear here.....I know what I am seeing....both in myself..and my wife.....and I see the entire picture here?  At least enough...to know where I am...and where my wife is....so I know what I need to do or what I can expect so I can act accordningly?  This is just a good summary of the all the possible peices and what they are?  The symptoms and the possbilities and what "might be" but not necessarily?

And just so you know, now refelcting back in time?  ODD....was really not my issue?  Maybe a "tad bit" here and there, but that really wasn't my "thang".  I got over that for the most part, even if there was a little in there, it wasn't an issue as much as other things for sure.  At least, not as much as some and it appeared to go away after a certain time which really was "my reality"....it why it's so confusing and so difficult to place one person with ADHD...compared t another?  I ge that now, more than ever before?  I have and had my own "thang" going on....but just to self report now after all is said and done?  ODD really wasn't a big "thang" or problem....and it wasn't then...and it still isn't now?  My wife....on the other hand.....that's a horse of a different color.  I get it and I see the picture clearly now if I didn't  before?  My hair is far less on fire as it has been....since I got the answers to the "WHY" question....which is contained in this article?  Either you see it....or you don't?  I couldn't see it, until I had all the pieces and then put the puzzle together enough and that was all I needed?   I think that is the bottom line?  Know thine own self....that's the key.

There are several self-reporting tools used to screen for adult ADHD. Examples of these scales include the Wender Utah Rating Scale and the Copeland Symptom Checklist for Adult Attention Deficit Disorders. Although use of self-reporting scales in adults has been shown to accurately describe ADHD symptomatology,[18] the scales lack specificity. Additional measures are needed to assist in making the diagnosis of adult ADHD.[19,20] Rating scales may aid in monitoring the symptoms and course of the disease.

The differential diagnosis of ADHD must exclude comorbid psychiatric conditions, such as major depression and substance abuse. Medical conditions in the differential diagnosis include hyperthyroidism, hepatic disease, intoxications, and sleep-disordered breathing.[21] A thorough medical evaluation, including a thyroid panel, serum lead level, and urine drug screen, are indicated to rule out these disorders. No specific neuropsychologic testing is recommended for the diagnosis of ADHD, but it may be useful when the diagnosis is uncertain. The testing should be individualized for each patient.[20]

Personality traits have been associated with adults who have ADHD,[22] particularly an increased incidence of mild histrionic traits. Adults with ADHD and comorbid disorders demonstrated avoidant and dependent personality styles. When oppositional defiant disorder occurs with ADHD, avoidant, narcissistic, antisocial, aggressive-sadistic, and negativistic traits are often found.

http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/442882_3

J

Another one of those "tid bits" that my T gave me as a tool to use.  As he said...."are you going towards something?  Or are you going away from it?"  As I see my wife rigth now, with all that we've gone through, she's been "going away from something" the entire time....and she's still doing it......right now this very minute?  And I....to the best of my ability and to the best I am able....have been going towards something?  We have been like two ships passing in the night...the entire time.  I get that...and see that clearly.

J

J

thank you for your detailed posts. I enjoy reading your prospectives. I admit I did read this one in its entirety so please correct me if I'm on the wrong line of thinking here. My h and I go thru this why thing a lot with me being the one with the question. I think I ask that because i see the same behavior time and time again and somehow I'm hoping that he will really think about the why and some kind of light bulb will go off and he will realize this is not a circumstantial issue but a habitual symptomatic issue and then I'll get a response that makes me feel like he gets it! Unrealistic I know! The "can we talk" syndrome where she talks you listen is another merry go round we get on and I have realized I do this and not to excuse it but here's the "why" for me. I basically feel like I've heard every rationalization excuse justification known to man and until I hear some accountability and acceptance of responsibility I really don't want the same old bs. I'm not saying you do this but mine does and I frankly can't take it anymore. 

You want to hear something funny?  I'll start with what you said and then comment on a couple of things.  I ( think ) I have finally got this "WHY"?....answer or riddle solved.  I'm laughing at myself for being so stubborn but in this case, it's one of "those" times that something was telling me something, and that something was "right".  It was in part, a feeling, a sense or just plain not understanding what I was looking at?  But making this simple.....I was seeing, and experiencing "something"...that just wasn't right?  Here we are, and my wife is moving out....and even with that, I have never experienced anyone behave or act the way she does in any of the 100's  ( maybe thousands by now )of different situations we've been in where it's like "huh??" ( scratching ).  Not only that, but I have never known anyone who was so "self unaware"....but in the weirdest of ways?  I mean, this is all brand new to me and I've got to say this straight up front.  I've been with a woman who was Borderline and not just one, but possibly a couple?  One confirmed by a therapist and others suspected as such?  And then there's my family members with my mom and my sisters and this mentioned of "mild Histrionic" traits.  Okay....got a life time of expereince with that too.....mostly my middle sister who is undiagnosed ADHD.  And my older sister is undiagnosed ADHD ( definitely inattentive )  OMG!!  Inattentive and then some?  Highly intelligent though, to the point that she really figured shit out on her own and she has her "ways".  Don't try and get in the middle of "her ways" though.....she will protect those babies like they are Fort Knox.  But.......she functions ( highly ) because she has created a system that absolutely works for her and she is like clockwork in precision.  She is "consistant" like there is no tomorrow, just don't ask or make her change from her system and everything is hunky dory.  And her husband seems to be fine with it but he use to travel all the time for work, and he like lots of space and time away to do his own thing so that's just fine with my sis and him apparently with "lots of space" betwee them?  Some people are like that...and they are those people.  If she was married to someone else.....they probably be her complaining?  I'm thinking?

The other sis....is kind of spastic ( my own endearing word for her...she is my sister and I Love her to death )...but she kina spastic none the less and is a little bit all over the place.  Always late, always got every waking minute of the day planned or penciled in with someone....and she is a like a Doctor who over-books and doesn't leave enough room or margin for any overages.  The appointments at the end of the day.....are the people who have to wait the longest since each appointment, she runs over 5 or 10 minutes and by the end of the day....it can be an hour or an hour an a half by that time so if she says 5pm.......I automatically add and hour and I know I will be safe?  Last time we had dinner scheduled when she was in town....she told me to meet her at 5:00pm.  I added 30 minutes and stopped for gas which put me almost 40 minutes late for our dinner date.  I got there at 5:40pm..and my phone rang and it was my sister.  Okay, nothing new, I expected it but I just guessed early this time?  She say she will be there in 10 minutes and it was 15 minutes when she arrived for a total of 55 minutes late which for her.....that's doing pretty good?  It was Mexican so I got some salsa and some chips and a Margarita and watched the Baseball game in the bar.

This is my life.  These are my family members snd there is nothing here that phases me on tiny bit?  My sister being an hour late for dinner. HA!  Waiting on the women in my house was a way of life?  No problem......this thing about "lying" if you wanted to pin that on my sister?  Ha!!  She would not lie to anyone, if her life depended on it?  She is the most trust worthy person I know? ( one of them )  And she is simply beyond "Christian"....she lives and breaths it, every single day.  And then there was my mom?  Forget about! LOL   At her wake and memorial....I gave a Eulogy that was specifically designed to be able to tell a crowd of people things or stories about my mother that had to do with this kind of "special relationship" we had....going all the way back to my teen age years when my sisters were gone out of the house and it was just me, my dad and mom?  

You have to understand one thing here.  I....was NOT use to ....being an only child.  By age 12 ( which was when my other sister left home for college ) I had my program down and I was just fine flying under the radar and keeping a low profile?  And mostly, it was because of my mom.  She had a tendency, to focus very intensely....on who ever she was focused on...and who she was focused mostly on my spastic sister, or lets say, more on the one with some "histrionic tendencies".  Fine with me!!!!  It was NOT the kind of attention I was looking for let me tell you?

So when the eye of Sauron...turned my way......I was already just starting to be a rebellious teenager.....this simply did not do and I made that pretty clear!! LOL  This began, this weird relationship, where I began to teach my mother in just how things really were? LOL  NOT, the other way around?  But in those years and especially when my father traveled and it was just my mom and I.......we had some really interesting conversations where I was going  "um........... ( I think there's something wrong with my mom LOL )"  In fact, I knew there was...and told her so straight up right out of the blue?  And what she told me was facinating and I will always remember this?  She said....she knew something was wrong when she was about 30 but never told anyone ( so she was actually telling me...the first and only person she told )  And she said.....that she knew ( your father ) would never go for paying for a pyschologist....but she knew she said....and had resigned her self to her station and this was it for her.  That was when I was about 16 or 17 ans further....she made this cryptic comment about....."wishing we could do more for you" which I was going  .....what  does that even mean?   Spit  it out...will you? errrrrrrr"!!!  LOL  And...Who's this (we) here by the way?.....I only see you here talking to me MOM!!" LOLerrrrrrrr"!!!  LOL  And...Who's this (we) here by the way?.....I only see you here talking to me MOM!!" LOL

So to say, I haven't seen it all......might be a mild understatement but really.......I've been with a number of woman over the years in both married and unmarried situations ( in may shapes and sizes ) and I didn't think you could throw something at me, that I had never seen before?  Until now.......and this totally freaked me out!!!  And I will admit....in my moments of utter despair and exasperation with someone or something that was so bizzarre acting.....that I would yell at her and throw my hands up and go ":You're a Freak!!  Freak of Nature!!!  What the Fuck is Wrong with YOU!!!!"  errrrrrr!!!!!   Which I'm not proud of ...but I had just hit the wall one too many times plus this person was aggressing on me at the time which just added to this and then some!  Hostile aggressive...not passive aggressive!! LOL  But still.....something wasn't adding up, and when things don't add up...I can be kind of bull dog and ferreting out the truth or fining out what that is?  It was be there waiting until I finally find out so I'd rather find out sooner than later even IF......the person is gone?  I really hate mysteries unless they come with some kind of answer to the crime or some ending to them that can put it to rest?

So this is a completely different WHY than I have ever encountered before?  Which is where I can start with what you said now and make a couple of comments to it just to start?  As you said "The "can we talk" syndrome where she talks you listen is another merry go round we get on and I have realized I do this and not to excuse it but here's the "why" for me. I basically feel like I've heard every rationalization excuse justification known to man and until I hear some accountability and acceptance of responsibility I really don't want the same old bs. I'm not saying you do this but mine does and I frankly can't take it anymore."
 

There's something you have to know or keep in mind here?  I laid out my ADHD to my wife in great detail.....I warned of her specifically of my limitations and spelled it out to her ahead of time and gave her ...or handed her on a silver platter, all my weakness and so on in an effort to almost "talk her out of being with me".  Almost, but not quite.  Someone, who has strong Narcissistic qualities....will have a strong tendecy..to start targeting your weak points and go after them as a menas to start breakding you down.  When you tell someone point blank  "hey...here are my weakness's"  and further, when "can we talk comes" and the why question comes from her?  I can tell you straight up what my answer go her was?  "Hey, do not you not recall me saying that this is my weakest thing?  That this is directly tied to my ADHD?  Did you not recall, our talk about my plan of action?  How I am taking actions steps one  by one and doing them just as I said I would?  Do you not recall us having a long and detailed conversation...about this plan:  What I was going to do?  How I was going to do it?  How long this would take?  How long that would take?  That I'm doing them in this order   1 , 2 , 3....rigtht out of the book?  Just like the BOOKS said?  Do you not recall, me saying this?  Do you not recall  US talking a bout this already?  Do you not recall....that we already talked about this?  And now, here we are talking about it again?  do you not recall...any of that?  Plus......it apears to me, you are singling out.....only the things I am absolutely worst at....you want to keep reminding me daily, how I fail.  What the Fuck is wrong with you!!!  You Freak!!"    

The last part I just threw in there because it still frustrates me but I have a better idea now of what this is?  When someone comes to you in the morning..and they say can we talk?  And you tell them during that talk, you are going to do something, and you give them a time frame you will do it in...and you anser them directly and say "I will do this by this time on Sunday.....and it's Wednesday morning.....and on Wednesday afternoon, they bring it up again, and you give them the same answer...to the same question, and then later that day say late in the afternoon....they bring it up again  ( on Wednesday ) and you go, "ah....you know, asking me 3 times the same day when I told you Sunday ...and it's still Wednesday....sounds like  ( two sylobols ) sounds like....you think, if you keep asking the same question over and over.....you will get a different answer than Sunday?  Sounds like......you think?  If you keep on pstering me, it will get doen sonner even though....you agreed Sunday would be fine?  Sounjds like  Sunday, is not fine and you changed your mind?  Sounds like that to me?  What the Fuck is the problem here?

Anger irritations, blaming blah blah blah  from her.  Throw it back in my face or even if I'm nice....there is some kind  of double talking going on as an answer?

Then later, that evening....now there's a written note on the counter...a note dealing with the same topic hand written right where I can't miss it........and it;'s Wednesday night?  And we had that "can we talk converstation that morning?"

That right there, is bizarre and unsual? LOL  and that right there when I would come to the end of my rope on the same day...I mean, WTF???   4 times....and the last one when I called her on the 3r5d one...she leaves me a note instead of speaking cause she knows full well that 3 strikes and she out....so she has to sneak another one in the back door and serrapticously leave a note......thinking that somehow thats not the same thing?  I mean really?  I've seen it all  ( ADHD included ) but I have never seen that in all the years I;ve been on this planet and that is when I scream  "FREAK"....caus that just freaks my shit out!!! LOL  It's like an evil clown that follows you around and is waiting arojund every corner?  ( I have a thing about clowns...ever since the movie Poltergeist LOL )You nevere know when she will strike next and come at you again with the same thing that you just talked an hour ago...or like a kid in the back seat on a car trep saying...."are we there yet"  but at least with a kid, you can yell at them and tell them to put a lid on it and they will listen to you when it gets to that point? LOL  I mean really?

And that one just happened this week?  LOL  I kid you not?  One of hundreds or maybe 1000's of those....never ending, on a constant basis?

Anyway....our T has confirmed PTSD with my wife and even wrote a letter for her job so she can work 4 days instead of 5 ( 4 10's ) so that way, she can no lose her job, but at the same time, comes home more irriated and aggrevated than before.  And as I was wrigting this, she came home and within 5 minutes, asked if "we can talk" again ( just now )...in an irritated voice and I just now told her  " can it wait until I'm finished here unless it something postive or it's not going to tell me something I didn't do ( fidning my weak ness again after  2 mintures in the door ) and she got angry and pissy and said  "this is why I'm leavning".  Specifically, she got angry because I didn't drop everything, to come her what "I had done wrong" which I'm sure, is something related to something that she "told me to do" and I know exactly what it is.  I never agreed or said...."I will do this thing".....she was walking out the door and gave some "command" and I didn't do it, but I never said I would?  Like she thinks, she can just bark out and order...and step and fetch it will imediately "jump to" and do it?  The difference is......I ignore those "commands"...until she learns to act like a decent human being instea of this "person " she  becomes which I know sho that person is by the sound ofthat voice?  That voice bbelongs to Mini Me.......and I don't not hear Mini Me or respond to Mini Me ....or speak or acknowledgte Mini Me.....as if Minim Me is not even there?  and Mini gets really pissy when Mini gets ignored.  Tough shit Mini.....you're SOL on that one.  errrrrrr! LOL  This literally just happend  as I was writing this?  And I am laughing now...because that negativity is coming to and end.  The evil clown will no longer be lurking and I can relax and do what I need to do...as I have been the entire time?  That I speled out to her indetial with a detiled plan of attack.  That she see's me doing...but will never ackowledge it?

Thkis is now, what I think I"m seeing?  No one has mentioned this before, I just stumgled across this the other day?  Oh, and I found out from her just this week a few more bits of the puzzle...and no, there was no alchoholism with her mother at the time she was born or pregnant with her ...nor with her borther at the time.  Her real father as I found out, dspite any of his failings which I have heard of.....was a tea totaler, and didn't drink alchohol except or rare occasins.  And her mother, was 18 and moved straight from her familys home when she got pregnant with my wife..and that family had no alchohol in the house...so alchohol was not even in the equation?  Just found that out this week...for the first time ever hearing about that?

Putting 2 + 2 together now.....I stumbled on CPTSD....COMPLEX POST TRAMATIC STRESS SYNDROME...or Developmental Trauma Disorder...which had this list of symptoms.

attachment <-----huge

neurobiology & physiology

emotional regulation and processing

core identity of self is fragmented and incoherent

cognitive and behavioral regulation is challenging

also huge: CAN BE CAUSED BY EMOTIONAL NEGLECT ALONE <--- which often prevents a person from getting help or identifying any trauma in their lives as we have yet to fully explore neglect as commonly as more clearly identifiable traumatic 'events'

flashbacks can often present as "emotional flashbacks" or "Somatic flashbacks" without the reliving of a memory through visual or auditory sensation.....these are scary and confusing and less discussed than the flashbacks we usually hear about or see played out on TV

Repeated traumatization, typically during childhood and developmental years

A real or perceived sense that one cannot escape, totalitarian control, authoritarianism, power over dynamics  ***  ( note )  percieved or real......meaning, I'm a passive guy...I'm not into the whole dominating and controlling thing.  That's not who I am

The 'self' literally developed within pervasive trauma/neglect and lack of ability to escape these conditions which makes seperating onesself from the truama freaking hard and complicated and scary. There is no 'before the trauma' for us. 

Folks with CPTSD can often exhibit the outwardly signs recognized with PTSD such as anxiety and avoidance behaviors, but they have literally developed their identities within the containers of trauma, neglect unable to make external changes to their environments to bring relief. Because there was an inability to create external changes to protect or remove onesself, the person learns to make deep internal changes, often absorbing as fundamental truths the insidious lies of the traumas in order to survive. 

Because of this, relationships can be some of the most challenging and in fact terrifying things to navigate as they are the actual battle ground where the original traumas occurred. Imagine if all the ways you learned to understand yourself, what you can expect from others and your role in the world was shaped through neglect, gas lighting, manipulation, shame, physical,  sexual and psychological boundary violations and isolation. At the core of CPTSD is the very real struggle for trust, especially trusting yourself. The primary relationship that is most damaged in ongoing developmental trauma is the relationship we have with ourselves AND it is the one we have to fight the hardest to get back. 

With CPTSD and chronic developmental traumas, the stories shaping how we see ourselves are all emerging from serious fucked up-ness. There typically isn't a pre-traumatic event place/self to refer to. So we just think we are crazy. And bad. And we operate to a high degree on beliefs and assumptions about safety that we don't even know we have.

That the world is inherently unsafe (because it totally was)

That people are unsafe (because they were) and ultimately going to hurt you

That shame and self-blame and inherent lack of self worth are TRUE reflections of our unworthiness (we were shamed for natural feelings and needs)

That we are inherently BAD. Unavoidably, unfixably BAD (because it was unsafe to see the abusers and neglect as bad during developmental stages so it is internalized and redirected at the self).

That we cannot trust ourself or there is no actual self to trust

That these realities cannot be fixed or changed but instead need to be hidden or conquered through becoming better/more worthy/more likable

All I can say is.....light bulb.  ( ding )

I have to say that my T did tell me that he wasn't thinking my wife was Borderline....but as I have come foind in reading more on this,, these two conditons apopear very similar and have some overlapping features.  Like I said, something wasn't right...and somng wasn't adding up...untill I got a bit more information from my wife....and Bingo...I think the glass slipper fit like a glove this time.  I had no idea there was thid dignosis out there which was made distinct from regular or normal PTSD?  Attachemnts alone...or any other epxlaination just wasn't hitting the mark?  Like the woman who wrote this who has this issue said....there's a whole lot of Fucked up in there...and this is what wasn't right.  Nothing fit until I got enough info out of her to see it go ...finally!!

So there you go...the last peice of the puzzle.

ASnd FYI:  My wife just came an apologized.  As she almost always does.  That just doesn't fit....with what I know in these other things like Narciisism or Borderline>  That's a different kind of Fucked up...and just like me, I got my own brand of Fucked up...it's just not one of these. LOL  For what it's worth.  I still contend that she is a decent person who is struggling tremendously...but has no control...or is inclined at all to do anything about it?  That's really all I got to say?

J

 

Good morning J

i responded to this but it didn't post due to website issues! 

I just wanted to say that my thoughts and prayers are with you and your wife today. I'm thinking it may be somewhat of a difficult day and I wanted you to know you are both being lifted up! 

 

That was very thoughtful to remember but I think I'm doing Okay and my wife seems so too?  I have to say that I have been dealing with her well and dealing with this transition as it comes.  The quite obvious and most telling thing in all of this is observing how when there is not demands for "closeness or intimacy".....my wife has gone back ( almost immediately ) to being a pretty civil person.  Even as I was explaining how she came home last night and started in.....I just told her I'm not going there and she of course reacted kind of "as usual" but then imediately calmed down and said she was sorry?  With no demands to be intimate or close...or any threat from me there now.....suddenly she's just fine?  No problem?  Which I could take as some kind of indicator of her feelings for me as she doesn't care or has none.......that's not what I'm seeing at all?  What I'm seeing is exactly what I said?  I pose no "threat" to her now.....so now she sees me completely differently?  Not completely indifferent in fact...and increase her her awareness of me and actually being very nice?  I am seeing this....not a sign that anything has changed......I see this for what it is....and just part of the overall pattern?  Nothings changed there....except, on my part and how I am approaching her and she is responding in kind?

The "threat of intimacy" is gone now....so I am no longer a threat?  In that much......I can't complain, I see it for what it is an accept it as much.  Thank you again, for you well wishes I think I'm going to be Okay and that's a good thing.

J

Yes Yes Yes!!!! So true! Spot on! Maybe I'm really not a crazy person!!!!

After reading this I actually sent this to our previous therapist,a psychologist by the way, and told him that he did damage to us and if he was not willing to educate himself in the effects of ADHD in marriages he should do the right thing and refer those couples elsewhere. I believe it is his obligation especially at $175 and hour!  Doubt it will do any good but at least I tried! 

Hi anteight,

Can't write more right now, as I'm in the middle of something. For now, I just wanted to say I'm glad my comments helped and I think you're doing great, considering the circumstances. A letter to therapist might not do any good for them, but that's also a way to do something good for yourself. These people are supposed to be your helpers and your guides. They should be more reliable.

In case you haven't heard of it, there's this book, "Is it You, Me, Or Adult A.D.D.?" It's always a great resource, and it's worth every cent you spend on it. And If you're looking for further validation, just read from page 161. Large excerpts are available on Google Books. I'm no longer allowed to access those pages (exceeded the limit for free version), but I've checked my paper copy and I think this might be exactly what you're looking for. The chapter ends with case accounts, you might find it really interesting.

I'll say that again: "Dear therapist, read a f*** book."

Stay strong.

Thank you! I will get it right away!  

Hi anteight,

Please let me know your thoughts after you start reading! And don't be a stranger, please update us on how things are, ok?

Take care.

Hi bigsurprise

i actually haven't got the book yet due to car issues however they are thankfully cleared up now! I'm thinking I may just buy the audio. I have however read some of her stuff esp on meds. I've forwarded them to my h and his counselor. I told him what he does with the info is of course his business. We have have been communicating today via text which is the first real communication since last wed as I had asked him to leave me alone. Apparently he had a good two hour session with his T who by the way is the sp of the co-author of Melissa's second book Recovery Intimacy. I am meeting with Nancie individually. He really wants to talk and wants me home but I've told him at this point I'm not coming home and I don't know what I want. Just taking it day by day. I could change my mind quickly or it could take months or it could be never. I can't give him an answer. I feel that he needs to get his meds reevaluated and continue his own therapy and time will tell. How he responds to having to wait it out and knowing the outcome will tell me a lot. 

Thanks for checking in. I hope you are doing well!!!! It's hard to stay strong!