My DH and I started out arguing last night, but ended up with a new understanding. I wish we did not have to fight to get to the gold nugget, but alas, that is just the way it works sometimes. I have been working really hard in the last week or so (well okay, with a few setbacks along the way). But my DH has not mentioned noticing anything. I was beginning to think that if I am working as hard as I can and he doesn't even notice, am I EVER going to make any progress (with him)?! I know that one week does not make a new lifestyle, especially with my ADD (two weeks is usually my max on any "new program"), but it's still all I have to offer. I can't go back and change the past; all I can do is change today. And I was really NEEDING some encouragement! I started a conversation with him about this last night. At first, he was very defensive and I was surprised at the anger I heard in his voice--he is generally a very even-tempered kind of man. Once we got past some of that, I broke down a little bit and explained that I was being totally vulnerable with him and giving everything I have to give. I wondered aloud if he had even noticed and whether it would ever be enough? I told him that I didn't think he could possibly understand how hard this is for me and that I KNOW we're in a really "bad place" (he keeps saying that) but I'm doing everything I know how to do to try to fix it. Will it be enough?
What he was thinking is interesting...
He sort of admitted that he had been holding back on commenting about the good things he had noticed in the past week (then he proceeded to list all of them...a long list--he really IS paying attention!). So why was he withholding the encouragement that I crave? Because he was afraid that by acknowledging my improvements, I would hear a "back-side" criticism instead of encouragement...that I would think he was pointing out all the things that NEED improvement and it would hurt me. Well, dang! I had to convince him that hello, I HAVE ACKNOWLEDGED how bad things are. I KNOW things need to improve. I am begging for help FROM A PSYCHIATRIST, for goodness' sake (I was literally filling out the questionnaire for my ADHD official evaluation as we were talking)!! I am not in denial here! He conceded that I have been very vulnerable, open and non-defensive about the whole thing, which is not typical for me. But he is totally confused about what he is supposed to be doing and how to help. I get that. I really do. Because I don't really know what he should be doing either. That is why I want a coach or counseling for us from someone who has a clue. Because we obviously don't. But what I DO know (and told him) was that I need to start getting some encouragement or at the very least, for him to express that he is NOTICING what I am doing, or it is going to be very difficult for me to stay motivated to work so hard. I don't mean that it's his job to be my cheerleader, and even if he DOESN'T do those things, I still have to keep working--I know that. But I really NEED to feel his support if at all possible; it will make this so much easier and probably much more successful for both of us. I think he is beginning to get that now, so hopefully that will help.
About 2 years ago when I first started seeing a counselor (for myself), I had VERY low self-esteem due to 40 years of untreated ADD, and I could not figure out how in the world this man could possibly love me. I asked him why he loves me? It took a LONG time for him to answer...many months, in fact. Finally, an answer came...he said it's because I LOVE HIM. Well, now that is a REALLY sweet answer, I know. But it was not really what I was looking for at all. What I needed was an acknowledgement of some sort of gift(s) of mine that he appreciates, in spite of all my many shortcomings. But I never told him that--it would have hurt his feelings after he tried to give me such a thoughtful answer. The sermon at church yesterday was on family life, and how family members' personalities are often like oil and water. And how we often try to shake up the oil and water (change the other person), but how much continued force it takes to keep those mixed together (if left alone, they will just separate again!). The point was that we need to see the value in each other the same way God sees value in each human being. This brought back to my mind the question of what VALUE do I really bring to my marriage or my DH? So I asked him (almost the same question as "Why do you love me?"). This time he gave me another very sweet answer...because I make him a better person. I soften his rough edges and force him to consider others' feelings and to deal with not always getting his way. However, this is still not in any way about my personal gifts or value--except that putting up with me makes him more tolerant. But when I pointed that out, he got angry and said that is exactly the kind of interpretation he was expecting to begin with--that I would hear the "back side" of a compliment and take it as a criticism.
Then after some more anger and defensiveness from him and a bunch of tears from me, he FINALLY got what I was saying...that I need to know what he loves ABOUT me. He thinks that is a totally different question than WHY he loves me--to me they are one and the same, but I guess I can see that there might be a difference? Then it finally dawned on him that it makes total sense that I would need that, and that our kids need that, and that everyone he has a relationship with needs that. And so he promised that I WILL know. He needed some time to process everything, which is fine with me. He "processes" things internally and very logically and deliberately before acting or speaking, while I "process" things by talking and rambling out loud in circles. I have totally accepted over the years that we are different in this way. So I don't mind waiting for him to think through it. I was just so glad that he finally understands what I was saying and asking (I hope)! And I think he genuinely believes that I am working really hard, even if he cannot quite understand it yet.
So while the discussion itself was not very pleasant, I do consider this to be PROGRESS we are making, so I posted it under this forum.

Comments
Going Well!
Just a quick update that things have been going quite WELL since this talk with my DH. He has been trying really hard to be more encouraging...or AT LEAST less critical! I'm excited about the progress. ALSO...I have been doing well myself. I have been fairly productive for a lot longer than my normal "spurts." Not perfect, of course, but much more consistent than usual. YAY!!!
Re: I asked the same question
I've asked the same question from my adhd husband before. There are times (once in a great while) I've really needed some sort of validation from him as to "why" he loves me. He only SAYS he loves me if I say it first, then he will repeat it, but never initiate the phrase, " I love you". Anyway, when I tried to explain to him that I would feel really good if he could "tell" me some of the things he thinks are "good" about me. (I try to say as many positive and affirming things to my husband as possible, to let him know he's important in many different ways to me). Well, he couldn't think of any GOOD things about me. So, I used an example, and told him things like... I like your hands because they are very strong, but yet they hold me gently and tenderly. I like your sense of humor and you do funny jokes, just to make me laugh, etc.......... Anyway, he couldn't think of ANYTHING to say about me. I thought maybe I overwhelmed him and/or put him on the spot, so I smiled and said, "Just tell me ONE THING that you really like about me, and that makes you smile or something. He couldn't think of ONE THING. I was dumbfounded. I tried to hide my disappointment, and just shrug it off, but it was there. Maybe I was wrong to ask, and I tried to explain further, but even later on, he couldn't think of anything. I felt stupid, terrible and confused. And he thought I was dumb for asking such a question.
Dedelight4, I am so sorry
Dedelight4,
I am so sorry for your disappointment. I don't really know what to say to help you feel better and I wish I did have an answer. I can say though, I asked my husband the very same question quite a few times now (been married close to 9 years) and his reply the first time was 'because I love the way you organize the plastic lids in the plastic cupboard'. I was SO upset with him for that response! Every other time I've asked him I've gotten absolutely no answer at all. I am sharing this so you know you are not the only one and I hope your husband can find a way to express his feelings to you.
Hang in there!
Weird
Weird that this is such a common theme. You would think almost ANYBODY could think of ONE THING that you like about ANYBODY! I haven't really gotten an answer yet either. Things are better between us lately, but I would still like to hear something from him on this question. It SEEMS fairly obvious that this is a need and it SEEMS like it should be easy--so why is it so hard to meet?
Part of our 'homework' once
Part of our 'homework' once in counseling was for us to write down the things we loved about our spouse. It was during a particularly difficult time and I literally sobbed because I could not think of not one single thing that I loved about him at the time...God that was devastating.
I bet that if I asked him this question he could tell me many things about me that he loves....he is never short on compliments and telling me how much he loves me...and why. He often thanks me for 'putting up with' him too. Nice to see something today that reminds me of his good traits. 90% of the time he tells me he loves me first. It isn't on purpose, or me intentionally not telling him, it is just he says it spontaneously a lot more than I do.
Hmmm
I used to say that a lot to my dh--thank you for "putting up with me." It was almost a standard comment of mine when signing cards. But I have tried to stop saying that. My counseling helped me realize how often I put myself down and how destructive those kind of thoughts can be for me--my confidence and self-esteem. Now I try to focus more on my good qualities and change the "tape" in my head. I just wish HE could do that too. He THINKS he is doing a lot better, but he is still making little comments that hurt my feelings (totally unconsciously). Earlier tonight he sent me a file on email that he wanted me to print because he was typing it on his ipad and can't print from there. He will need it sometime tomorrow but he reminded me 2 or 3 times tonight. And when I looked irritated about his reminders, he told me he knew I would still forget. I finally just printed it right then to PROVE that I wouldn't forget. And earlier I cooked dinner. For some reason, this is one of my hardest areas, but today I planned ahead and even marinated the meat ahead of time, EVEN THOUGH I had to take our daughter to the doctor late this afternoon because she has strep throat. Normally that kind of unexpected interruption would totally wreck any plans I may have had for the rest of the day. But I still made it to the store and cooked a meal. Then when he was getting a drink out of the fridge for dinner, he noticed some leftovers from the weekend and said we could have eaten leftovers and we should definitely eat those tomorrow. Um, SERIOUSLY?!?!
This man would NEVER be intentionally mean. But it is almost unbelievable that he could be so insensitive. And yet he wants a pat on the back for being so much more encouraging lately. Huh? He has mentioned that a few times now and I can't see how he thinks he is being encouraging except that maybe he is not being quite as CRITICAL (maybe)? I guess that's better than nothing, but not what I really consider encouraging. So I guess we both have to put up with each other! This is how my perspective has changed (improved?) in the past couple of years. I can finally see that HE is not perfect either. 'Cause I really used to think he was. In my own assessment, he was perfect and I was scum. Now I think we're pretty even...somewhere in the middle! Still wish he would (could?) tell me something he loves about me...or at least what he LIKES. I am having to work hard to find things I like about myself, and as I discover them, I am growing less and less patient all the time with waiting for him to see them too. Then again, as someone told DF recently, why do I get to grow impatient after just a few weeks when he has had to accept my faults (mostly unknown to me then) for YEARS? I guess I owe him some time to figure things out.
Ok...playing devil's advocate
Ok...playing devil's advocate here...I don't see anything wrong with the 'leftovers' suggestion. I'm just curious why you took that as an insult? As a non-ADHDer, I wouldn't take that as any kind of insult to you...but maybe I'm missing something. I will go out on a limb and guess that you felt you were doing a great job...preparing in advance, taking your daughter to the doctor, and still getting home in time to make a nice, fresh meal. How does his comment about leftovers completely diminish all of that in your mind? Can you try and see them as two separate things? Him seeing food that needs to be eaten/not wasted and commenting about how you should have it for dinner tonight is one thing. Your efforts to make an nice meal last night, compounded by the trip to the doctor, as another? Why would you automatically assume that his comment was in some way tearing down your efforts for last nights meal? How about, instead, you DON'T be offended by it and instead say "yes, we will definitely have those tomorrow, but tonight I wanted this" and let that be it? Why would his off the cuff comment about leftovers make you feel so bad about yourself? I'm not saying he isn't guilty of saying things that might be hurtful...I cannot know for sure...but in this case there is room for questioning whether this is HIS issue or YOUR issue. I wouldn't give a shit if my husband said "we should have had those leftovers" it wouldn't bother me in the least. I make what I make..and if he eats, fine..if not, fine. It is food. It doesn't dictate who you are or your value in his life. If you pick at things like this and feel bad over every thing he says, you'll exhaust him...YOU are going to have to learn to let things go and stop assuming his intentions were negative and just carry on with your life. You say he'd never intentionally be mean...so that might be a good indication that you're being overly sensitive about things that you shouldn't be.
I can see how his constant reminders irritate you..why they would..I get that. I do the same to my husband because honest to God if I don't, he forgets. If he prints it, he forgets to bring it home. It's not right, but it is just a knee jerk reaction to the fear that if you don't do it NOW it won't get done, ya know? I certainly don't mean to make him feel bad about himself...and I know I probably irritate him too, but the truth is, he's not extremely reliable sometimes, and if I am in a position where I have to rely on him, it usually only gets done with a lot of reminders. It is what it is. I asked him to carry in the dog food the other day...he said he would shortly. Never did. Hungry, starving dogs didn't even motivate him to 'remember'. I didn't remind him, did it myself, and he remembered a few days later and felt bad. Should I have reminded him? Either way, according to this, I would make him feel bad. What are we to do?
NO ONE is perfect...and you need to stop NOW feeling like you're trying to live up to anyone's expectations. You will make mistakes...we all do. You're trying...your husband knows...let that be enough for now. RELAX! :)
Good Points!
Thanks, Sherri. Those are all very good points. And today, when I am not so close to it, what you say makes perfect sense! You are right that I should be giving him the benefit of the doubt if I KNOW he would never intentionally be mean. That's what I want him to do for me too, so I should offer the same respect to him! And I think I took the reminders so personally because I knew I was NOT going to forget. But of course, he didn't have any assurance of that, especially given my track record of forgetting things easily. So once again I am expecting him to read my mind and somehow just know that THIS TIME he can depend on me. Grrr--I need a good kick in the pants sometimes! Not EVERYTHING has to be analyzed and picked apart all the time. Thanks for being my reality check tonight! :)
By the way, tonight I had to take our daughter to play practice right around dinner time. My DH came home from work and heated up all the leftovers for himself and our older kids, even leaving everything out for me and my daughter to eat when we got back home. He's really a good man--I should be grateful...and I am! And your reply to my post reminded me to be sure to tell him so. Thanks.
I meant to add... I think
I meant to add...
I think love is an action...more than a feeling...and it might be very hard for me sometimes to put into words why I love him, but I do. Even when I could not think of one single reason I loved him, it didn't mean I didn't love him. That is the 'feeling' part of it. Maybe for many ADHDers, actions are easier than feelings...doing things (staying in the marriage, helping around the house, providing for the family) probably feels like an act of 'love' and putting into words what exactly it is probably feels like climbing a mountain..with a straight jacket on. My husband has put me on the spot by asking me this question before...and I hate it...and I'm not ADHD. I love him. My heart longs to have him in my life. He is my best friend. I want to grow old with him. Sometimes things specifically about him that are lovable are scarce...but the feeling is still there.