My husband has continual conversations in his head but is then convinced that he’s had the conversation with me. When I question it he says I’m wrong and we argue. It’s like he’s gaslighting me constantly. I’ve tried to stay calm and the last time it happened I reminded him exactly how the conversation had gone without raising my voice and he eventually remembered what we’d discussed.
It’s like he has his own script that he thinks he’s said out loud but then gets angry when I disagree because I know that’s not what was said and when it contradicts his decisions, it’s extremely hard to understand what he wants me to do or say. Any advice? Is this common with ADHD?
I made this mistake also...At any point me, you, or anyone in life attempts to correct an adult who is convinced in their minds enough to argue about something (anything)...And we take it up with words also...Then we just opened the door for toxic dysfunction...Because we are allowing ourselves to be controlled...We allow ourselves to be their puppets...In other words nothing good, respectful, or constructive will ever come from that dialog...
A lot of the time the reason we allow ourselves to get drug into it is, because if we say no, that you are remembering it wrong, then attempt to walk away...That's never good enough for them...And it's not, but, only in their minds!...It's called a boundary, the only effective one's are the one's we place on ourselves, and keep!...It's never our job to calm, disarm, or correct someone who is adamant about something that only proves the faultiness of how their mind works...That is why you, me, and many of us have ended up on this site over the years...Refusing to let them be them, (mothering and co dependence) and not demanding that they will have to do the same thing with us...(acceptance of different realities)...If we don't stop trying to get in each others minds, the dysfunction and high emotions never end...
It is similar to dementia patients...The staff on dementia units just smile hear the story and acknowledge and never contradict what is going on in their minds...Of course we can't actually ignore our spouses, but, once we hear an untruth, or a part truth, we can say no and walk away...The only way to address this type issue is....By addressing them first (ignore the issue)...."If you want to stop talking and set down and calmly listen w/o interrupting, I will tell you how I remember it once!...But once I tell you, it's over, no more debate, it's over, and if you don't respect that it's over, all you will get from me, is my back...It's up to us to create and maintain the boundaries (to not take part or be manipulated into it) when it comes to out of control mental ramblings, that can quickly turn emotional when the truth can't be remembered or accepted...
Until a husband or wife in these situations can say "I am not your mother, walk away w/ no remorse, there is very little hope for that relationship...Of course, they ALWAYS do well alone...No one to mother them...
I’m not sure I feel mothering is the right phrase but maybe you’re right. It’s just so hard to convince him at times that he’s not sharing his thoughts but him thinking he is!
We really do not know what each other has or is currently dealing with...I just know that to continue to engage (attempting to fix, or speak into) the same disrespectful actions of any kind, with many ADD minds can create a comfort level in the person doing it...(They get so use to the combative dialog, they don't even realize how disrespectful and peace forfeiting it is) With my former ADD wife, she was all over the place emotionally and looked to blame...(never took ownership)...So disengaging and letting her work through her own stuff (memory, time management, what ever) without my input (which was hard for me) was the only way she was forced to be an adult w/out looking to blame...
Hopefully you do not have this going on...Sorry I sounded to harsh...
I realise it’s not harsh words but I suppose I feel sorry for someone who has ADHD - not because it’s detrimental to them as a person, quite the contrary. I’ve seen first hand how adaptable my husband can be at looking outside the box. Spontaneous and confident. All things I’m not but I do feel bad that he can be so misunderstood. I almost feel I need to apologise for his behaviour at times. He can be quite blunt but somehow it gets him results!! The inner thoughts are hard though. I think if I can stay calm and highlight what’s happened, he will see - eventually! It’s hard though, so hard to stay calm when I’m raging inside!
With my ex, I would find myself facing consequences of ‘decisions we’d made’ that I had been completely unaware of. On one occasion this involved him cancelling a lovely hotel so we could go stay with his ex girlfriend instead. Apparently we’d agreed this. I would never have agreed this; not in a million years. I ended up changing beds and making conversation with a woman I disliked rather than relaxing in a hotel. With him I thought of it as convenience rather than actually believing we had had the conversation. He preferred to stay with her and so that was what he decided would happen.
I really did love him, and he broke me again and again. I kept pulling myself back together and working harder. After half a lifetime of this - 25 when I met him, together for 25 years - I collapsed, physically and emotionally, and could not pull myself back together again, even for the kids. This past year - just 10 months in fact since we split - I have been gradually reassembling something like myself, and reassessing his behaviour and no longer finding excuses for it.
Maybe I didn’t love him enough, or maybe I loved him too much, I don’t know. But I did love him. I trusted him, believed in him, and I believed in us. And it very nearly destroyed me. So I would not assume that love will fix things, or that whoever eventually gives up does so through lack of love.
During divorce, my ADD ex was deceitful and hurtful, explaining he hadn’t valued our years together, and that he was happy to get rid of me. It was hard to hear since I’d been his caregiver for years, supporting him financially and carrying the family responsibilities alone.
Then, a year later with no attempts from him whatsoever to make peace, he apparently told my mother he had conversations with me in his head every day. He was mulling about how things had gone wrong, and wanted to make amends. But he never reached out to me with a single word of all those internal conversations. They were all in his head.
That’s tough. I think anyone who has adhd realises after they’ve spoken harshly that they shouldn’t have and do regret their actions but it’s hard to tolerate for the non adhd partner.
Perhaps ADHDers think they do communicate when having private thoughts. It’s also very possible the outcome for their partner in these scenarios is in no way intended.
I think as long as I could still believe my ex didn’t want to hurt me, it was all bearable. But once I lost that faith, I plummeted. He’d probably say today if somebody asked him, that he never wanted anything but good things to happen to me. Still, being married to him has made me lose confidence, health, social circles, and finally seems to have given me cPTSD.
Not saying you’re in for the same. Just trying to point out how hard it can be when one’s not lucky with one’s partners symptoms.
At least hearing that others have had the same issues I can be assured it’s not me and I’m not going crazy. It does make me question my own sanity at times and I end up thinking my memory is going! I just wish I knew how to respond when he is convinced he’s told me something when in reality he hasn’t and it’s all his own internal thoughts.
How do I respond without sounding like I’m just up for an argument. It’s draining at times and I feel like I’m walking on eggshells.
It sounds like you don’t share reality with him, and that leads to conflict. You’re looking for ways to avoid the conflict? It also makes you feel like you’re losing your mind?
I’m certainly no expert, but it seems safer to me to be honest about the discrepancy. Yes, there will be open conflict. But if you hide the conflict, you are suddenly no longer participating on your own terms, and you’ll allow him to cross your emotional boundaries without even knowing it.
Being very clear about where you stand and your reality is putting the relationship to the test. And whether differences are reconcilable or not, you’ll find out sooner than later. This I imagine is a good thing. There are therapeutic options offered by Melissa if you need to have such conversations with your partner in an expert context.
However loving and resourceful you are, you can’t make a good relationship on your own. He needs to respect your reality and accommodate your needs as well, or you won’t be happy.
My husband and I used to fight about this all the time. Now, it's less often. Because of my own issues with long covid and anti-depressants, I have little short term memory. And my husband has constant running conversations in his head with me, co-workers, parents, etc... I am new to this group and am overjoyed to read about others struggles. Not in a mean way! But to see that there is hope. And ideas for coping. One that I am using for these "conversations" is to take notes (verbal or manual utilizing notes apps) when we are making plans, discussing schedules, having financial discussions, or anything else that I don't want to forget. It helps me to remember, and it helps him to realize that not everything was said out loud. He didn't like it at first, but found out that it cut down on some of the arguments.
I’m also new to this site after buying the book which was very helpful but you can’t beat talking to real people who are going through it too. I’m not going crazy and neither are you!
Sorry to hear about your health issues.
I’m not sure how I’d write things down. Sometimes it’s more about doing something together and hubby will say for example “no I said do it that way’” when clearly it was a discussion in his head or he won’t discuss plans because he’s ’thinking things through’ or ‘I’ve got this attitude’ which as a married couple I find infuriating as surely, being a couple means discussing options for planning things.
Besides the ADHD he is the best husband I could wish for. This is my second marriage and I value the fact that he’s loyal and trustworthy and hardworking but he has a very independent mind set where it’s his way or not at all. Is that ADHD or arrogance!?
Hey Groot! What do you think about you and your hubby taking a few quick notes on your conversations for a couple of weeks to see if that works. E.G. -talked about the wedding this weekend, -leaving at 6, -husband picking up suit at dry cleaners Wednesday.
Just something simple that reminds you both what you've discussed so when he has these moments where he thinks you've had a conversation about something, he can see that you haven't without the need for an argument. It also might show him that there is a pattern of this happening so maybe he'll argue less with you and simply believe you when you say something was never discussed.
Have him sign off on the notes so there is proof of his agreement. Often times there is a disconnect with remembering what was said and what they agreed to. At least you won't be gaslit when you whip out the paper with his signature. But then again, he may deny signing it and accuse you of forgery. Anything to wiggle out of responsibility.
Asking him to sign something is great in theory but knowing my husband he would definitely not agree to that. So far, I’ve found it good to be firm, but fair in gently reminding him of exactly how things were discussed. He might not agree straight away but I leave it with him and invariably he accepts things and we move on. It’s hard but I’m following the advice of Jefferson Fisher who says your first response to any response should be a breath or maybe even say nothing. It’s tough but it’s a good starting point.
I find one of the most exasperating things with my ADD ex his avoidance of keeping promises. He would agree to something, then act as if that agreement was never made. He’s highly intelligent, though his judgment seemingly clouded with years of mental illness. Though I used to grudgingly accept his flakiness as an ADD symptom, I now see him as a person lying to avoid binding commitments. Possibly because an ADD mind knows itself and that they won’t want to follow through on promises later on. But they make promises to make the present more peaceful.
The breaking of promises that preceded our divorce was unacceptable. I’ve suffered severely from it and no longer care what reasons my ex had for his deceit.
In fact, I’d strongly advise against making any agreements with a person who refuses to sign them. It may look like the person takes offense that you don’t trust them. In reality, it shows the person knows you should not trust them.
For your posts. I’ve long believed my ADHD spouse was both having conversations in her head and confusing issues with with her exes ( she’d told me about) for issues with me. What I did at the time was gently but firmly advise her “that” conversation never occurred with me, and ask her if perhaps she’d rehearsed it to have with me and would like to give me more detail and context so I could respond. As for the other confusion, I was very lucky to know who she was actually confusing me with and point out, not me but “X”, right? Back then she registered confusion but didn’t become defensive. I appreciate your posts—I’d noted this phenomenon but never associated it with her ADHD previously.
Not only have I validated your experience which I’m really happy about but in your reply to me, you have confirmed that I’m not going crazy! That in itself makes things easier to cope with as now I know, he’s not looking for an argument - he genuinely believes what’s been said as having actually happened!
Today, was a classic example. He was writing something and read it back to me as he wanted my opinion on what he’d written. I told him it sounded great, but then, and get this, he joked, crikey I don’t trust your proof reading skills, as you’ve missed a spelling mistake! I hadn’t even read it - he read it out to me but was convinced I’d read it! He’d read from his phone which at no time did he hand it to me to read!!! I laughed and made a joke of it and it thankfully defused any situation that before I might have got cross at.
This whole thread has been so enlightening for me and I’m taking on board all the comments made.
Thank you everyone!
Comments
Conversations are in his head!
I’m desperate for some advice!
My husband has continual conversations in his head but is then convinced that he’s had the conversation with me. When I question it he says I’m wrong and we argue. It’s like he’s gaslighting me constantly. I’ve tried to stay calm and the last time it happened I reminded him exactly how the conversation had gone without raising my voice and he eventually remembered what we’d discussed.
It’s like he has his own script that he thinks he’s said out loud but then gets angry when I disagree because I know that’s not what was said and when it contradicts his decisions, it’s extremely hard to understand what he wants me to do or say. Any advice? Is this common with ADHD?
Hi Groot Lover...
I made this mistake also...At any point me, you, or anyone in life attempts to correct an adult who is convinced in their minds enough to argue about something (anything)...And we take it up with words also...Then we just opened the door for toxic dysfunction...Because we are allowing ourselves to be controlled...We allow ourselves to be their puppets...In other words nothing good, respectful, or constructive will ever come from that dialog...
A lot of the time the reason we allow ourselves to get drug into it is, because if we say no, that you are remembering it wrong, then attempt to walk away...That's never good enough for them...And it's not, but, only in their minds!...It's called a boundary, the only effective one's are the one's we place on ourselves, and keep!...It's never our job to calm, disarm, or correct someone who is adamant about something that only proves the faultiness of how their mind works...That is why you, me, and many of us have ended up on this site over the years...Refusing to let them be them, (mothering and co dependence) and not demanding that they will have to do the same thing with us...(acceptance of different realities)...If we don't stop trying to get in each others minds, the dysfunction and high emotions never end...
It is similar to dementia patients...The staff on dementia units just smile hear the story and acknowledge and never contradict what is going on in their minds...Of course we can't actually ignore our spouses, but, once we hear an untruth, or a part truth, we can say no and walk away...The only way to address this type issue is....By addressing them first (ignore the issue)...."If you want to stop talking and set down and calmly listen w/o interrupting, I will tell you how I remember it once!...But once I tell you, it's over, no more debate, it's over, and if you don't respect that it's over, all you will get from me, is my back...It's up to us to create and maintain the boundaries (to not take part or be manipulated into it) when it comes to out of control mental ramblings, that can quickly turn emotional when the truth can't be remembered or accepted...
Until a husband or wife in these situations can say "I am not your mother, walk away w/ no remorse, there is very little hope for that relationship...Of course, they ALWAYS do well alone...No one to mother them...
Good luck!
c
That seems quite harsh
I’m not sure I feel mothering is the right phrase but maybe you’re right. It’s just so hard to convince him at times that he’s not sharing his thoughts but him thinking he is!
Not meant to be harsh, just strait to the point...
We really do not know what each other has or is currently dealing with...I just know that to continue to engage (attempting to fix, or speak into) the same disrespectful actions of any kind, with many ADD minds can create a comfort level in the person doing it...(They get so use to the combative dialog, they don't even realize how disrespectful and peace forfeiting it is) With my former ADD wife, she was all over the place emotionally and looked to blame...(never took ownership)...So disengaging and letting her work through her own stuff (memory, time management, what ever) without my input (which was hard for me) was the only way she was forced to be an adult w/out looking to blame...
Hopefully you do not have this going on...Sorry I sounded to harsh...
c
I get it! Thank you
I realise it’s not harsh words but I suppose I feel sorry for someone who has ADHD - not because it’s detrimental to them as a person, quite the contrary. I’ve seen first hand how adaptable my husband can be at looking outside the box. Spontaneous and confident. All things I’m not but I do feel bad that he can be so misunderstood. I almost feel I need to apologise for his behaviour at times. He can be quite blunt but somehow it gets him results!! The inner thoughts are hard though. I think if I can stay calm and highlight what’s happened, he will see - eventually! It’s hard though, so hard to stay calm when I’m raging inside!
Have seen this too
And my ADD ex partner was actually angry and disappointed at me for not having heard him.
As you say he’s your ex - was
As you say he’s your ex - was it the ADD that broke it for you?
Oh yes
Sadly. I loved him dearly, but the ADD has ruined it.
yes
With my ex, I would find myself facing consequences of ‘decisions we’d made’ that I had been completely unaware of. On one occasion this involved him cancelling a lovely hotel so we could go stay with his ex girlfriend instead. Apparently we’d agreed this. I would never have agreed this; not in a million years. I ended up changing beds and making conversation with a woman I disliked rather than relaxing in a hotel. With him I thought of it as convenience rather than actually believing we had had the conversation. He preferred to stay with her and so that was what he decided would happen.
Sorry to hear this. I love my
Sorry to hear this. I love my husband dearly so I’m determined to make it work.
I did too
I really did love him, and he broke me again and again. I kept pulling myself back together and working harder. After half a lifetime of this - 25 when I met him, together for 25 years - I collapsed, physically and emotionally, and could not pull myself back together again, even for the kids. This past year - just 10 months in fact since we split - I have been gradually reassembling something like myself, and reassessing his behaviour and no longer finding excuses for it.
Maybe I didn’t love him enough, or maybe I loved him too much, I don’t know. But I did love him. I trusted him, believed in him, and I believed in us. And it very nearly destroyed me. So I would not assume that love will fix things, or that whoever eventually gives up does so through lack of love.
Sorry to hear that. It’s hard
Sorry to hear that. It’s hard at times. I don’t want use the adhd as an excuse for his behaviour. I’m guessing there’s a big learning curve for me.
Things in his head
During divorce, my ADD ex was deceitful and hurtful, explaining he hadn’t valued our years together, and that he was happy to get rid of me. It was hard to hear since I’d been his caregiver for years, supporting him financially and carrying the family responsibilities alone.
Then, a year later with no attempts from him whatsoever to make peace, he apparently told my mother he had conversations with me in his head every day. He was mulling about how things had gone wrong, and wanted to make amends. But he never reached out to me with a single word of all those internal conversations. They were all in his head.
That’s tough. I think anyone
That’s tough. I think anyone who has adhd realises after they’ve spoken harshly that they shouldn’t have and do regret their actions but it’s hard to tolerate for the non adhd partner.
Perhaps they think they communicate
Perhaps ADHDers think they do communicate when having private thoughts. It’s also very possible the outcome for their partner in these scenarios is in no way intended.
I think as long as I could still believe my ex didn’t want to hurt me, it was all bearable. But once I lost that faith, I plummeted. He’d probably say today if somebody asked him, that he never wanted anything but good things to happen to me. Still, being married to him has made me lose confidence, health, social circles, and finally seems to have given me cPTSD.
Not saying you’re in for the same. Just trying to point out how hard it can be when one’s not lucky with one’s partners symptoms.
Thank you for your honesty
At least hearing that others have had the same issues I can be assured it’s not me and I’m not going crazy. It does make me question my own sanity at times and I end up thinking my memory is going! I just wish I knew how to respond when he is convinced he’s told me something when in reality he hasn’t and it’s all his own internal thoughts.
How do I respond without sounding like I’m just up for an argument. It’s draining at times and I feel like I’m walking on eggshells.
Conflict about reality
It sounds like you don’t share reality with him, and that leads to conflict. You’re looking for ways to avoid the conflict? It also makes you feel like you’re losing your mind?
I’m certainly no expert, but it seems safer to me to be honest about the discrepancy. Yes, there will be open conflict. But if you hide the conflict, you are suddenly no longer participating on your own terms, and you’ll allow him to cross your emotional boundaries without even knowing it.
Being very clear about where you stand and your reality is putting the relationship to the test. And whether differences are reconcilable or not, you’ll find out sooner than later. This I imagine is a good thing. There are therapeutic options offered by Melissa if you need to have such conversations with your partner in an expert context.
However loving and resourceful you are, you can’t make a good relationship on your own. He needs to respect your reality and accommodate your needs as well, or you won’t be happy.
Best of luck.
Thank you
Great advice. Thank you.
Oh, yes.
My husband and I used to fight about this all the time. Now, it's less often. Because of my own issues with long covid and anti-depressants, I have little short term memory. And my husband has constant running conversations in his head with me, co-workers, parents, etc... I am new to this group and am overjoyed to read about others struggles. Not in a mean way! But to see that there is hope. And ideas for coping. One that I am using for these "conversations" is to take notes (verbal or manual utilizing notes apps) when we are making plans, discussing schedules, having financial discussions, or anything else that I don't want to forget. It helps me to remember, and it helps him to realize that not everything was said out loud. He didn't like it at first, but found out that it cut down on some of the arguments.
Nice to know I’m not alone!
I’m also new to this site after buying the book which was very helpful but you can’t beat talking to real people who are going through it too. I’m not going crazy and neither are you!
Sorry to hear about your health issues.
I’m not sure how I’d write things down. Sometimes it’s more about doing something together and hubby will say for example “no I said do it that way’” when clearly it was a discussion in his head or he won’t discuss plans because he’s ’thinking things through’ or ‘I’ve got this attitude’ which as a married couple I find infuriating as surely, being a couple means discussing options for planning things.
Besides the ADHD he is the best husband I could wish for. This is my second marriage and I value the fact that he’s loyal and trustworthy and hardworking but he has a very independent mind set where it’s his way or not at all. Is that ADHD or arrogance!?
Taking light notes?
Hey Groot! What do you think about you and your hubby taking a few quick notes on your conversations for a couple of weeks to see if that works. E.G. -talked about the wedding this weekend, -leaving at 6, -husband picking up suit at dry cleaners Wednesday.
Just something simple that reminds you both what you've discussed so when he has these moments where he thinks you've had a conversation about something, he can see that you haven't without the need for an argument. It also might show him that there is a pattern of this happening so maybe he'll argue less with you and simply believe you when you say something was never discussed.
Great idea
I can certainly give it a go. Thank you!
Have him sign it
Have him sign off on the notes so there is proof of his agreement. Often times there is a disconnect with remembering what was said and what they agreed to. At least you won't be gaslit when you whip out the paper with his signature. But then again, he may deny signing it and accuse you of forgery. Anything to wiggle out of responsibility.
Not sure he’d agree
Asking him to sign something is great in theory but knowing my husband he would definitely not agree to that. So far, I’ve found it good to be firm, but fair in gently reminding him of exactly how things were discussed. He might not agree straight away but I leave it with him and invariably he accepts things and we move on. It’s hard but I’m following the advice of Jefferson Fisher who says your first response to any response should be a breath or maybe even say nothing. It’s tough but it’s a good starting point.
Avoiding to sign an agreement
I find one of the most exasperating things with my ADD ex his avoidance of keeping promises. He would agree to something, then act as if that agreement was never made. He’s highly intelligent, though his judgment seemingly clouded with years of mental illness. Though I used to grudgingly accept his flakiness as an ADD symptom, I now see him as a person lying to avoid binding commitments. Possibly because an ADD mind knows itself and that they won’t want to follow through on promises later on. But they make promises to make the present more peaceful.
The breaking of promises that preceded our divorce was unacceptable. I’ve suffered severely from it and no longer care what reasons my ex had for his deceit.
In fact, I’d strongly advise against making any agreements with a person who refuses to sign them. It may look like the person takes offense that you don’t trust them. In reality, it shows the person knows you should not trust them.
Validation and thanks
For your posts. I’ve long believed my ADHD spouse was both having conversations in her head and confusing issues with with her exes ( she’d told me about) for issues with me. What I did at the time was gently but firmly advise her “that” conversation never occurred with me, and ask her if perhaps she’d rehearsed it to have with me and would like to give me more detail and context so I could respond. As for the other confusion, I was very lucky to know who she was actually confusing me with and point out, not me but “X”, right? Back then she registered confusion but didn’t become defensive. I appreciate your posts—I’d noted this phenomenon but never associated it with her ADHD previously.
Glad I’ve validated things for you.
Not only have I validated your experience which I’m really happy about but in your reply to me, you have confirmed that I’m not going crazy! That in itself makes things easier to cope with as now I know, he’s not looking for an argument - he genuinely believes what’s been said as having actually happened!
Today, was a classic example. He was writing something and read it back to me as he wanted my opinion on what he’d written. I told him it sounded great, but then, and get this, he joked, crikey I don’t trust your proof reading skills, as you’ve missed a spelling mistake! I hadn’t even read it - he read it out to me but was convinced I’d read it! He’d read from his phone which at no time did he hand it to me to read!!! I laughed and made a joke of it and it thankfully defused any situation that before I might have got cross at.
This whole thread has been so enlightening for me and I’m taking on board all the comments made.
Thank you everyone!